Letters to the Editor: No Butts

In the midst of so much disease and uncertainty, there is something that individuals can do to improve their own well-being, as well as their communityโ€™s health. There is no better time to quit smoking or vaping tobacco (or other substances) than during this pandemic.

Studies show that smoking and vaping compromise the immune system and weaken the lungsโ€™ defenses. Sadly, for children and other vulnerable populations, exposure to secondhand smoking or vaping aerosols (including both nicotine and cannabis) increases the risk of respiratory diseases including Covid-19 and makes recovery more difficult.

Those sharing a household or an apartment wall with residents who smoke are also at higher risk. Luckily for smokers and vapers, plenty of free resources are available to help them quit.  Many people make health-related New Yearโ€™s Resolutions in January. If you know anyone struggling with this type of addiction, please share this with them.

The California Smokersโ€™ Helpline (nobutts.org) offers personal support via phone and text, plus a free two-week starter kit of nicotine patches, while supplies last. Also, the Smoke-Free Marin Coalition (smokefreemarin.com) is launching a county-wide campaign to help people quit smoking and vaping tobacco (and other substances) in the New Year.

Our Tackling Tobacco Team at San Rafaelโ€“based Bay Area Community Resources (bacr.org) supports individuals of all ages who want to quit and provides free resources, such as a new YouTube Channel created to help individuals quit during the pandemic.

Anita Renzetti

Project Director

Adult Cessation Services

Bay Area Community Resources

Popular Family Series Returns For Virtual Season of Shows

Back when social gatherings were possible, the Luther Burbank Center for the Arts in Santa Rosa hosted world-class performers and artists as well as nationally-recognized education programs and popular community events such as the Clover Sonoma Family Fun Series.

This year, as Covid-19 keeps forcing live events to go online, Luther Burbank Center for the Arts continues to host events online, and the center recently announced that the Clover Sonoma Family Fun Series is returning in 2021 with five free virtual performances that will entertain and educate children and their families while they stay at home to slow the spread of the pandemic.

โ€œWeโ€™re thrilled not only to be able to offer the Clover Sonoma Virtual Family Fun Series this year, but to do so completely free to families.  Itโ€™s one way we can give back to the community that means so much to us,โ€ Melanie Weir, Luther Burbank Center for the Arts Education and Community Engagement Manager, says in a statement. โ€œThis is only possible because of the generosity of Clover Sonoma, Exchange Bank, and the Evert Personโ€™s Youth Access Fund supplied by the Ernest L. and Ruth W. Finley Foundation.โ€

The series kicks off on Saturday and Sunday, Jan. 23โ€“24, with โ€œPete The Cat,โ€ a musical adventure based on the book series by Eric Litwin. The song-and-dance show is produced by TheaterWorksUSA, which brings beloved productions to venues across the countryโ€“and now onlineโ€“for schooltime performances.

In February, the series mixes science and comedy with the bombastic โ€œDoktor Kaboom.โ€ The educational and engaging one-man performance showcases the scientific method using humor and explosive experiments that are actually tied directly to curriculum standards. The Doktor goes kaboom on Saturday and Sunday, Feb. 21โ€“22.

Next up, โ€œThe Snail & the Whaleโ€ tells the heart-warming story of a tiny sea snail hitching a lift on the tail of a giant humpback whale on Saturday and Sunday, Mar. 13โ€“14. The virtual production, inspired by Julia Donaldson and Axel Schefflerโ€™s acclaimed picture book, teaches lessons on friendship while providing live music and fun that is appropriate for audiences ages four and up.

In April, the massively popular โ€œDiNO Lightโ€ show streams into homes for a glow-in-the-dark adventure. Kidsโ€™ entertainment company CORBiAN Visual Arts and Dance, in collaboration with Lightwire Theater, brings the fan-favorite showcase to life with neon lights and cutting-edge technology. Families are encouraged to watch โ€œDiNO Lightsโ€ in the dark for the full experience when the show streams on Saturday and Sunday, Apr. 17โ€“18.

Finally, bilingual kidsโ€™ music sensation Sonia De Los Santos shares her cheerful songs about nature, everyday life, and her own Mexican heritage in a virtual concert performance on Saturday and Sunday, May 15โ€“16. Singing in Spanish and English, De Los Santos s musically inspired by various Latin American rhythms from Mexico, Colombia and Peru as well as American folk traditions. For this performance, De Los Santos will also give online audiences a sneak peek into how she and her friends make music, as well as special cultural demonstrations.

Free tickets for Clover Sonoma Virtual Family Fun Series performances are available beginning Friday, Jan. 8 at 10am. Lutherburbankcenter.org.

How Bay Area Food Banks are Coping with the Pandemicโ€™s Hunger Crisis

Second Harvest Food Bank Development and Marketing Officer Suzanne Willis remembers when her Watsonville-based food pantry served about 55,000 people monthly, providing them with parcels of fresh produce and pantry staples. 

This was early in 2020, before the Covid-19 pandemic hit, prompting widespread business closures in March. After that, the number climbed to approximately 88,000โ€”an increase of 60 percent.

Part of the problem is that each winter, tourism and agricultural jobs dry up. That means families need help to feed themselves and to survive, even in a year without a pandemic.

โ€œIf youโ€™re spending everything you have on rent and medical and gas, you donโ€™t have the funds for food,โ€ Willis says. โ€œA lot of the work weโ€™re trying to do is make sure people have access to the fresh produce, the lean proteins and the whole grains they need, but also the knowledge on how to use it.โ€

Other Bay Area food banks have recorded similar surges in need. The Redwood Empire Food Bank, which serves families from Sonoma County to the Oregon border, reported a 300 percent spike in demand between March and April of last yearโ€”from 10,000 to 40,000 meals per month. 

Likewise, the San Francisco-Marin Food Bank now serves approximately 60,000 households each week, compared to 32,000 each week prior to the pandemic.

UC Berkeley sociology professor David Harding says that workers in tourist industries often face dueling vulnerabilities: they work in boom-or-bust economies, in areas with a high cost of living.

Harding says the pre-pandemic economy was actually pretty good at the start of 2020, in terms of markers like unemployment. But the U.S. generally has high levels of economic inequality compared to other wealthy democratic countries. So many Californians were already in a precarious spot.

โ€œOur economy is one that, even in the best of times, many working and middle-class families are living paycheck-to-paycheck and arenโ€™t able to prepare for a time like this when the economy goes south,โ€ says Harding, whose research interests include poverty, inequality, urban communities, race and the criminal justice system. โ€œIf people have to shelter-at-home and businesses are closed, it doesnโ€™t take long before people are struggling to meet their basic material needs. And weโ€™re seeing that.โ€

Sure enough, Willis says that during the Great Recession of 2008 and 2009, Second Harvestโ€™s numbers jumped from 30,000 people picking up food per month to 50,000, and they never went down. Then this year, staffers and volunteers watched demand soar past that level. Willis fears that a similar pattern will emerge in the wake of the pandemicโ€”and that demand will remain high for years to come. 

Information compiled by the nonprofit Feeding America shows that 9 percent of Sonoma County residents were food insecure, defined as not having reliable access to food, in 2018. The same year, 7.4 percent of Marin County residents and 7.9 percent of Napa County residents were considered food insecure.

And according to state data, the number of households receiving CalFresh food assistance Marin, Napa and Sonoma counties climbed 26.8 percent between February and June 2020.

Needing the Way

The effect of the pandemic on food security came swiftly. In a study released this past spring, researchers at Northwestern University found that food insecurity doubled nationwide in April of 2020 and tripled for families with children. 

In subsequent analyses, the two researchers found that the troublingly high levels held steady into the summer and that Black and Hispanic children remained much more likely to be food insecure than white kids were.

In December, an analysis of Census survey data by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP) found that approximately 27 million adults (roughly 13 percent of all adults) reported that they โ€œsometimes or oftenโ€ didnโ€™t have enough to eat in the past seven days. In 2019, only 3.4 percent of adults said that they did not have enough to eat at some point during the past 12 months, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Willis says the struggles of hungry families are often intertwined with housing insecurity, job insecurity and all forms of social, racial and economic injustices.

โ€œAll of it ties in together, and it all has this snowball effect on a person who maybe is kind of making it, and all of a sudden you throw in a broken car or a cancer diagnosis or something; that is the kind of thing that will throw a family on the edge completely over it,โ€ Willis says.

In general, Harding thinks it can be easy for many Americans to lose sight of what social scientists really mean when they talk about poverty. The typical definition of poverty, whether to a government agency or to an academic, is that someoneโ€™s income falls below a threshold, but what that really means is that someone doesnโ€™t have enough money to pay for their very basic needsโ€”food and housing. The resulting consequences can be devastating, especially as they fall on the nationโ€™s kids. 

โ€œTheyโ€™re pretty severe,โ€ Harding says. โ€œIf youโ€™re thinking about children, itโ€™s going to be influencing their social and emotional development. Itโ€™s going to be impacting their ability to apply themselves in school.โ€ He adds that initial rounds of federal stimulus helped, but the benefits wore off.

These problems extend far and wide, including to students at the stateโ€™s public universities, despite Californiaโ€™s efforts to expand services.

According to a report by the University of California Office of the President, between 39 and 47 percent of student respondents from the UC system were found to be food insecure in three surveys since 2016. Those figures were a few percentage points higher than for UC Berkeley alone. 

In May, the California Student Aid Commission (CSAC) conducted a survey of more than 70,000 college students and high school seniors to understand how the pandemic had affected them. The survey found that more than seven in 10 students had lost at least some of their income. 

In short, the pandemic pushed the everyday crises that many California college students face from โ€œsteadyโ€ to โ€œextreme,โ€ says CSU East Bayโ€™s Darice Ingram.

Ingram coordinates the Helping Our Pioneers Excel (HOPE) program, which oversees a food pantry and assistance for struggling student renters, while responding to students in crisis. Ingram helps educate low-income students about how they may qualify for CalFresh and also helps them apply. HOPE additionally provides Instacart credits to those who donโ€™t have enough groceries. And the program has been connecting students who moved out of the area for distance learning with resources in their regions. 

At least 30 percent of Cal State East Bay students are now food insecure, Ingram says, although she adds that the true states of hunger, poverty and homelessness can all be difficult to measure and track.

โ€œCollege students just find a way to make it happen, not realizing that theyโ€™re in crisis, because theyโ€™re college students,โ€ she says. โ€œTheyโ€™re like, โ€˜I gotta go to school, so I gotta make this happen. Iโ€™ll stay at my friend Johnโ€™s on Tuesday, and on Wednesday, Iโ€™ll stay over here, and on Thursday, Iโ€™ll stay in my car.โ€™ But they didnโ€™t identify as being homeless.โ€

Additional reporting by Will Carruthers.

Sonoma County Regional Parks Takes Ownership of 335-Acre Ranch Property

A large Sonoma Coast ranch property with sweeping views and ecological and historical significance has been transferred to Sonoma County Regional Parks with plans to ultimately open it to the public as a regional park and open space preserve.ย 

Ownership of the 335-acre Carrington Coast Ranch north of Bodega Bay near Salmon Creek was conveyed to the county agency Wednesday, Jan. 30, by the Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation and Open Space District.ย 

The site is primarily coastal grasslands, and features views of the ocean and Bodega Bay, cypress trees, historic buildings, Salmon Creek, coastal hills and coastal prairie. 

“Carrington Coast Ranch hosts a diversity of natural habitats, including coastal prairie, coastal scrub, freshwater and saltwater wetlands, and tidal marsh. Several special-status species, such as the Townsend big-eared bat, California red-legged frog and American badger have been identified on the property,” county officials said in an announcement. 

Buildings on the former dairy ranch include a homestead built before 1860 and considered to be one of the oldest buildings in Sonoma County. 

The district had purchased the property in 2003 for $4.8 million, originally with plans to transfer it to California State Parks, but that plan was never realized due to the state agency’s budget and staff constraints. 

“This project has been a long time in the making, so it is extraordinary to see the vision become reality and soon our community will be able to enjoy the rolling grasslands and beautiful vistas that make this property such a gem,” said Sonoma County 5th District Supervisor and Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation and Open Space District Director Lynda Hopkins. “The conservation of our working and natural lands, including this new park and preserve, provides so many benefits to Sonoma County’s diverse communities. These include addressing climate change mitigation and adaptation, offering a place for all people to enjoy nature and showcasing stunning scenic landscapes that define our region.” 

Sonoma Regional Parks is developing a master plan to guide development of trails, recreational and educational uses, and stewardship of natural resources, with public outreach for the planning process set to begin next summer.ย ย 

Opportunities for the public to periodically access the park and preserve will be developed in the interim. 

“Full of local history and ecological significance, this striking property, with its sweeping views from Jenner to Salmon Creek, Bodega Dunes, and Bodega Head showcases the southern Sonoma Coast. The gentle coastal terrace will offer accessible trails and diverse nature experiences for residents and visitors,” said Sonoma County Regional Parks Director Bert Whitaker. “We look forward to working with the community and our partners to steward the land and provide new opportunities for people to discover the magic of our coast.”

New Year Opens with Several Online North Bay Events

Even though 2020 is officially done and the New Year is here, the Covid-19 pandemic continues to make in-person gatherings a tricky endeavor in the North Bay. To help start 2021 in a positive way, several local events boasting music, art, history, poetry and other timely communal interests are happening online this week. Hereโ€™s a round up of whatโ€™s worth looking forward to.

Online Reading

The Rivertown Poets regularly meets twice a month at Aqus Cafรฉ in Petaluma to share poetry readings from guest writers and the community-at-large with a poetry open mic. In 2020, the group went online to continue the series virtually in the wake of the pandemic, and things are staying online in 2021. Rivertown Poets mark the first of itโ€™s โ€œAmuse-ing Mondaysโ€ of the year with a digital gathering featuring readings by published poets Patti Trimble and Robert Eastwood followed by an online poetry open mic on Monday, Jan. 4, at 6:15pm. Free. Aqus.com/online.

Online Event

Marin County residents and organizations resolving to get creative for the New Year can learn how to get on local television at the Community Media Center of Marin Orientation, held virtually in place of in-person events due to the pandemic. The CMCMโ€™s first orientation of 2021 offers insight into the centerโ€™s low-cost video production workshops, such as basic camera production and video editing, and how Marin residents can receive the necessary certifications for using CMCM equipment and facilities. Take the first step into television on Tuesday, Jan. 5, at 7pm. Free. Cmcm.tv.

Online Forum

Each month, the Marin County Commission on Aging hosts a meeting to discuss timely topics that directly impact the elder community in the region. This month, the commission hosts a virtual gathering that covers โ€œThe Intersection of Race and Age in Marin.โ€ The Zoom meeting will feature several Marin residents sharing their personal stories of how systemic racism in the North Bay has affected the older-adult community, along with expert opinions on the matter from Yashica Crawford, Ph.D., of College of Marinโ€™s psychology faculty. The free forum is open to the public and takes place on Thursday, Jan. 7, at 10am. Get details at Marinhhs.org.

Online Concert

Marin-based multi-instrumentalist and music educator Megan Schoenbohm uses her musical gifts to help children express themselves and to help families creatively connect to each other through interactive music classes. In addition to her classes, she makes acclaimed music for kids. Her debut children’s album, “Bubba & Boo,” won a Parents’ Choice Award and a NAPPA Award, and her second album, “You Are Enough,” won the 2020 Parents’ Choice Award. This week, Schoenbohm is the latest North Bay star to shine online as part of the ongoing โ€œLuther Localsโ€ concert series, hosted by Luther Burbank Center for the Arts on Friday, Jan. 8, at 5pm. Lutherburbankcenter.org.

Online Lecture

In July of 1974, Anita Fagiani Andrews was murdered at Fagianiโ€™s Cocktail Lounge in Napa, which she co-owned with her sister. The case went unsolved until 2011, when DNA evidence led to the conviction of Roy Melanson, who has been linked to several murders. Napa County Superior Court Judge Ray Guadagni oversaw that trial; now he writes about the case in the forthcoming book, The Napa Murder of Anita Fagiani Andrews: A Cold Case That Caught a Serial Killer. Before the bookโ€™s release, Guadagni shares his story in an online presentation hosted by the Napa County Historical Society on Friday, Jan. 8, at 7pm. Free. Napahistory.org.

Online Exhibit

The last 12 months have been unprecedented and challenging on many levels, with a medical crisis, ecological disasters and social-justice movements all converging in 2020. Throughout all of that upheaval, local artists and creative folks responded with meaningful works that reflect the current state of affairs and offer a glimpse into a hopeful future. This week, MarinMOCA showcases many of those salient pieces of art in the new exhibit, โ€œHere & Now.โ€ Juried by Bay Area gallery owner and curator Kim Eagles-Smith, the contemporary multimedia exhibit opens on Saturday, Jan. 9, at 500 Palm Dr., Novato, and online at Marinmoca.org.

Online Event

The Sonoma County Climate Activist Network kicks off 2021 with a new vision for progressive and transformative change with the online community summit, โ€œItโ€™s Up To Us.โ€ The interactive presentation includes information on how the activist network is helping the community connect to the land through education and action, and the summit boasts a lineup of guest speakers from local organizations such as The Greenbelt Alliance, The Climate Center, Singing Frogs Farm and the Sonoma Sunrise Movement. Join the summit and learn how you can help the North Bay go green on Sunday, Jan. 10, at 2pm. Free. Sonomacountycan.org.

‘Project Censored’ Spotlights 2020’s Buried News Stories

Every year since 1976, Project Censored has performed an invaluable service โ€” shedding light on the most significant news thatโ€™s somehow not fit to print. While journalists everyday work hard to expose injustices, they work within a system where some injustices are so deeply baked in that stories exposing them are rarely told and even more rarely expanded upon to give them their proper due.

Thatโ€™s where Project Censored comes in. 

โ€œThe primary purpose of Project Censored is to explore and publicize the extent of news censorship in our society by locating stories about significant issues of which the public should be aware, but is not, for a variety of reasons,โ€ wrote its founder Carl Jensen on its 20th anniversary.

Thus, the list of censored stories thatโ€™s the centerpiece of its annual book, State of the Free Press | 2021 doesnโ€™t just help us to see individual stories we might otherwise have missed. It helps us see patterns โ€” patterns of censorship, of stories suppressed and patterns of how those stories fit together.

The stories listed below are only part of what Project Censored does, however. State of the Free Press | 2021 has chapters devoted to other forms of obfuscation that help keep censored stories obscured. So, if the Top 10 stories summarized below leave you hungry for more, Project Censored has all that and more waiting for you in State of the Free Press | 2021.

1. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls

โ€œIn June 2019 the Canadian National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls released its final report, which received widespread news coverage in the United States,โ€ Project Censored notes.โ€œU.S. corporate news outlets have provided nearly nothing in the way of reporting on missing and murdered Indigenous women in the United States.โ€ 

Thatโ€™s despite a problem of similar dimensions, and complexity, along with the election of the first two Native American congresswomen, Deb Holland and Sharice Davids, who, Ms. Magazine reported, โ€œare supporting two bills that would address the federal governmentโ€™s failure to track and respond to violence against indigenous women [and] are supported by a mass movement in the U.S. and Canada raising an alarm about missing and murdered indigenous women and girls (MMIWG).โ€

Four in five Native women experience violence at some time in their lives, according to a 2016 survey by the National Institute of Justice, cited in an August 2019 Think Progress report.

โ€œAbout nine in 10 Native American rape or sexual-assault victims had assailants who were white or Black,โ€ according to a 1999 Justice Department report.

โ€œAlthough the number of Native Americans murdered or missing in 2016 exceeded 3,000 โ€” roughly the number of people who died during the Sept. 11, 2001 terror attack โ€” the Justice Departmentโ€™s missing persons database logged only 116 cases that year,โ€ Think Progress noted. โ€œThe sheer scale of the violence against Native women and the abysmal failure by the government to adequately address it, explains why the issue was given such prominence during this weekโ€™s presidential candidatesโ€™ forum in Sioux City โ€” the first to focus entirely on Native American issues.โ€  

But even that didnโ€™t grab media attention.

There are multiple complicating factors in reporting, tracking, investigating and prosecuting, which were explored in coverage by The Guardian and Yes! Magazine, as well as Ms. and Think Progress

โ€œCampaigners, including the Sovereign Bodies Institute, the Brave Heart Society, and the Urban Indian Health Institute, identify aspects of systemic racism โ€” including the indelible legacies of settler colonialism, issues with law enforcement, a lack of reliable and comprehensive data, and flawed policymaking โ€” as deep-rooted sources of the crisis,โ€ Project Censored summed up. โ€œAs YES! Magazine reported, tribal communities in the United States often lack jurisdiction to respond to crimes.โ€ 

This was partially remedied in the 2013 reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act, known as VAWA, but โ€œit left sex trafficking and other forms of sexual violence outside tribal jurisdiction, YES! Magazine reported.โ€ 

The House voted to expand tribal jurisdiction in such cases in its 2019 VAWA reauthorization, but, Ms. reported, โ€œThe bill is now languishing in the Senate, where Republicans have so far blocked a vote.โ€

Another facet of the problem explored by Yes! is the connection between the extractive fossil fuel industry and violence against Native women. The Canadian report โ€œshowed a strong link between extraction zones on the missing and murdered women crisis in Canada,โ€ Yes! noted. โ€œIt specifically cited rotational shift work, sexual harassment in the workplace, substance abuse, economic insecurity, and a largely transient workforce as contributing to increased violence against Native women in communities near fossil fuel infrastructure.โ€

โ€œIt creates this culture of using and abuse,โ€ said Annita Lucchesi, executive director of the Sovereign Bodies Institute. โ€œIf you can use and abuse the water and land, you can use and abuse the people around you too.โ€

Project Censored concluded, โ€œAs a result of limited news coverage, the United States is far from a national reckoning on its crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls.โ€

2. Monsanto โ€œIntelligence Centerโ€ Targeted Journalists and Activists

In its fight to avoid liability for causing cancer, the agricultural giant Monsanto (now owned by Bayer) creยญated an โ€œintelligence fusion centerโ€ to โ€œmonitor and discreditโ€ journalists and activists, Sam Levin reported for The Guardian in August 2019. 

โ€œMore than 18,000 people have filed suit against Monsanto, alleging that exposure to Roundup [weedkiller] caused non-Hodgkin lymphoma, and that Monsanto covered up the risks by manipulating scientific data and silencing critics,โ€ the Hill summarized. โ€œThe company has lost three high-profile cases in the past year, and Bayer is reportedly offering $8 billion to settle all outstanding claims.โ€

โ€œMonsanto adopted a multi-pronged strategy to target Carey Gillam, a Reuters journalist who investigated the companyโ€™s weedkiller,โ€ The Guardian reported.

The Guardianโ€™s report was based on internal documents (primarily from 2015 to 2017) released during trial. They showed that โ€œMonsanto planned a series of โ€˜actionsโ€™ to attack a book authored by Gillam prior to its release, including writing โ€˜talking pointsโ€™ for โ€˜third partiesโ€™ to criticize the book and directing โ€˜industry and farmer customersโ€™ on how to post negative reviews.โ€

In addition, Monsanto paid Google to skew search results promoting criticism of Gilliamโ€™s work on Monsanto, and they discussed strategies for pressuring Reuters with the goal of getting her reassigned. The company โ€œhad a โ€˜Carey Gillam Bookโ€™ spreadsheet, with more than 20 actions dedicated to opposing her book before its publication.โ€ They also โ€œwrote a lengthy report about singer Neil Youngโ€™s anti-Monsanto advocacy, monitoring his impact on social media, and at one point considering โ€˜legal action.โ€™โ€

The entire pool of journalists covering the third trial was also targeted in a covert influence operation, Paul Thacker reported for The Huffington Post. A purported โ€œfreelancer for the BBCโ€ schmoozed other reporters, trying to steer them toward writing stories critical of the plaintiffs suing Monsanto. Their curiosity aroused, they discovered that โ€œher LinkedIn account said she worked for FTI Consulting, a global business advisory firm that Monsanto and Bayer, Monsantoโ€™s parent company, had engaged for consulting,โ€ and she subsequently went into a digital disappearing act.

Chemical juggernaut Monsanto sought to discredit rocker Neil Young, who released a 2015 record, โ€˜The Monsanto Years.โ€™ Photo by Ben Houdijk

โ€œFTI staff have previously attempted to obtain information under the guise of journalism,โ€ Thacker added. โ€œIn January, two FTI consultants working for Western Wire โ€” a โ€˜news and analysisโ€™ website backed by the oil and gas trade group Western Energy Alliance โ€” attempted to question an attorney who represents communities suing Exxon over climate change.โ€

Nor was FTI alone. 

โ€œMonsanto has also previously employed shadowy networks of consultants, PR firms, and front groups to spy on and influence reporters,โ€ Thacker wrote. โ€œAnd all of it appears to be part of a pattern at the company of using a variety of tactics to intimidate, mislead and discredit journalists and critics.โ€

โ€œMonsanto officials were repeatedly worried about the release of documents on their financial relationships with scientists that could support the allegations they were โ€˜covering up unflattering research,โ€ The Guardian noted. 

At the same time, they tried to attack critics as โ€œanti-science.โ€ 

โ€œThe internal communications add fuel to the ongoing claims in court that Monsanto has โ€˜bulliedโ€™ critics and scientists and worked to conceal the dangers of glyphosate, the worldโ€™s most widely used herbicide,โ€ it summed up.

โ€œMonsantoโ€™s campaign to monitor and discredit journalยญists and other critics has received almost no corporate news coverage,โ€ Project Censored notes. 

A rare exception was a June 2019, ABC News report which nonetheless โ€œconsistently emphasized the perspective of Monsanto and Bayer.โ€

3. U.S. Military โ€” A Massive, Hidden Contributor to Climate Crisis

Itโ€™s said that an army travels on its stomach, but the Army itself has said, โ€œFuel is the โ€˜blood of the military,โ€™โ€ as quoted in a study, Hidden carbon costs of the โ€˜everywhere war by Oliver Belcher, Patrick Bigger, Ben Neimark, and Cara Kennelly, who subsequently summarized their findings for The Conversation in June 2019. 

The U.S. military is โ€œone of the largest polluters in history, consuming more liquid fuels and emitting more cliยญmate-changing gases than most medium-sized countries,โ€ they wrote.

If it were a country, it would rank as โ€œthe 47th largest emitter of greenยญhouse gases in the world.โ€

Studies of greenhouse gas emissions usuยญally focus on civilian use, but the US military has a larger carbon footprint than any civilian corporation in the world.

โ€œThe U.S. militaryโ€™s climate policy remains fundamentally contradictory,โ€ their study notes. 

Things will only get worse. 

โ€œThere is no shortage of evidence that the climate is on the brink of irreversible tipping points,โ€ the study notes. โ€œOnce past those tipping points, the impacts of climate change will continue to be more intense, prolonged, and widespread, giving cover to even more extensive U.S. military interventions.โ€

Understanding the militaryโ€™s climate impact requires a systems approach. 

โ€œWe argue that to account for the U.S. military as a major climate actor, one must understand the logistical supply chain that makes its acquisition and consumption of hydrocarbon-based fuels possible,โ€ the study states. โ€œWe show several โ€˜path dependenciesโ€™โ€”warfighting paradigms, weapons systems, bureaucratic requirements, and wasteโ€”that are put in place by military supply chains and undergird a heavy reliance on carbon-based fuels by the U.S. military for years to come.โ€

Data for their study was difficult to get.

โ€œA loophole in the 1997 Kyoto Protocol exempted the United States from reporting milยญitary emissions,โ€ Project Censored explains. โ€œAlthough the Paris Accord closed this loophole, Neimark, Belcher, and Bigger noted that, โ€˜with the Trump administration due to withdraw from the accord in 2020, this gap . . . will return.โ€™โ€ They only obtained fuel purchase data through multiple Freedom of Information Act requests.

Finally, by way of conclusions, Project Censored stated:

Noting that โ€œaction on climate change demands shutยญtering vast sections of the military machine,โ€ Neimark, Belcher, and Bigger recommended that โ€œmoney spent procuring and distributing fuel across the US empireโ€ be reinvested as โ€œa peace dividend, helping to fund a Green New Deal in whatever form it might take.โ€

Not surprisingly the report had received โ€œlittle to no corporate news coverageโ€ as of May 2020, beyond scattered republication their Conversation piece.

4. Congressional Investments and Conflicts of Interest

Exposition, political corruption and conflicts of interest are age-old staples of journalism. So, itโ€™s notable that two of the most glaring, far-reaching examples of congressional conflicts of interest in the Trump era have been virtually ignored by corporate media: Republicanโ€™s support for the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, and bipartisan failure to act on catastrophic climate change.

โ€œThe cuts likely saved members of Congress hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes collectively, while the corporate tax cut hiked the value of their holdings,โ€ Peter Cary of the Center for Public Integrity reported for Vox in January 2020. 

It was sold as a middle-class tax cut that would benefit everyone.

โ€œPromises that the tax act would boost investment have not panned out,โ€ he noted. โ€œCorporate investment is now at lower levels than before the act passed, according to the Commerce Department.โ€ 

Once again, โ€˜trickle down tax cutsโ€™ didnโ€™t trickle down.

โ€œThe tax lawโ€™s centerpiece is its record cut in the corporate tax rate, from 35 percent to 21 percent,โ€ Cary wrote. โ€œAt the time of its passage, most of the billโ€™s Republican supporters said the cut would result in higher wages, factory expansions, and more jobs. Instead, it was mainly exploited by corporations, which bought back stock and raised dividends.โ€  

A screenshot of Zoom call with Sen. Tom Carper, the top Democrat on the Environment and Public Works Committee, who has up to $310,000 invested in more than a dozen oil, gas, and utility companies.

Buybacks exceeded $1 trillion for the first time ever, the year after the cuts were passed, and dividends topped a record  $1.3 trillion high.

The benefits to Congressional Republicans were enormous. 

โ€œThe 10 richest Republicans in Congress in 2017 who voted for the tax bill held more than $731 million in assets, almost two-thirds of which were in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other instruments,โ€ which benefitted handsomely as a result of their votes that โ€œdoled out nearly $150 billion in corporate tax savings in 2018 alone,โ€ Cary noted. โ€œAll but one of the 47 Republicans who sat on the three key committees overseeing the drafting of the tax bill own stocks and stock mutual funds.

โ€œDemocrats also stood to gain from the tax bill, though not one voted for it,โ€ he wrote. โ€œAll but 12 Republicans voted for the tax bill.โ€

Two special features deserve notice. First is a newly created 20% deduction for income from โ€˜pass-throughโ€™ businesses, or smaller, single-owner corporations. 

โ€œAt least 22 of the 47 members of the House and Senate tax-writing committees have investments in pass-through businesses,โ€ Project Censored noted. 

Second was a provision allowing real estate companies with relatively few employees โ€” like the Trump organization โ€” to take a 20 percent deduction usually reserved for larger businesses with sizable payrolls.

 โ€œOut of the 47 Republicans responsible for drafting the bill, at least 29 held real estate interests at the time of its passage,โ€ Project Censored pointed out.

As to the second major conflict, โ€œMembers of the U.S. Senate are heavily invested in the fossil fuel companies that drive the current climate crisis, creating a conflict between those senatorsโ€™ financial interests as investors and their responsibilities as elected representatives,โ€ Project Censored wrote.

โ€œTwenty-nine U.S. senators and their spouses own between $3.5 million and $13.9 million worth of stock in companies that extract, transport, or burn fossil fuels, or provide services to fossil fuel companies,โ€ Donald Shaw reported for Sludge in September 2019. 

While unsurprising on the Republican side, this also includes two key Democrats. Sen. Tom Carper, of Delaware, is the top Democrat on the Environment and Public Works Committee. He has โ€œup to $310,000 invested in more than a dozen oil, gas, and utility companies, as well as mutual funds with holdings in the fossil fuel industry,โ€ Shaw reported. 

But his record is not nearly as questionable as Sen. Joe Manchin, of West Virginia, the ranking member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, who โ€œowns between $1 million and $5 million worth of non-public stock in a family coal business, Enersystems,โ€ and reported earning โ€œbetween $100,001 and $1 millionโ€ in reported dividends and interest in 2018,  plus $470,000 in โ€˜ordinary business income,โ€ Shaw reported. 

His support for the industry was significant:

Manchin was the only Democrat to vote against an amendment to protect the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge from oil drilling in 2017, and he was one of just three Democrats to vote against an amendment to phase out taxpayer subsidies for coal, oil, and gas producers in 2016. Manchin has also voted to approve construction of the Keystone XL oil pipeline, expedite the approval process for natural gas pipelines, and override an Obama administration rule requiring coal companies to protect groundwater from toxic coal mining waste.

While there has been critical coverage of 2017 tax cuts, this has not included coverage of lawmakers personal profiting, Project Censored noted.

 โ€œIn addition, despite the significant conflicts of interest exposed by Donald Shawโ€™s reporting for Sludge, the alarming facts about U.S.  senatorsโ€™ massive investments in the fossil fuel industry appear to have gone completely unreported in the corporate press.โ€

5. Inequality Kills: Gap between Richest and Poorest Americans Largest in 50 Years

โ€œIn public health, decades of research are coming to a consensus: Inequality kills,โ€ DePaul University sociologist Fernando De Maio wrote for Truthout in December 2019.

Even before COVID-19, his research added fine-grained evidence of broad trends highlighted in three prominent governmental reports: the gap between rich and poor Americans had grown larger than ever in half a century, according to the U.S. Census Bureauโ€™s 2019 annual survey, with dramatic evidence of its lethal impact: people in the poorest quintile die at twice the rate as those in the richest quintile, according to a report by the Congressional General Accounting Office. And, this is partly because job-related deaths are increasingly rooted in the physical and psychological toll of low-wage work, as opposed to on-the-job accidents, as documented by the United Nationsโ€™ International Labor Organization.

All these conditions were made worse by COVID-19, but they could have been seen before the pandemic struck โ€” if only the information hadnโ€™t been censored by the corporate media, as Project Censored noted:

As of May 2020, Project Censored has not been able to identify any corporate news coverage on the GAO or Census Bureau reports on inequality and premature mortality, or on the ILO report about work-related illnesses, accidents, and deaths that take place when workers are off-duty.

The August 2019 GAO report was based on health and retirement surveys conducted by the Social Security Administration in 1992 and 2014, looking at those between 51 and 61 years old in 1992, and dividing them into five wealth quintiles.

โ€œ[T]he GAO found that nearly half of those (48 percent) in the poorest quintile died before 2014, when they would have been between 73 and 83 years old. Of the wealthiest quintile, only a quarter (26 percent) died,โ€ explained Patrick Martin, writing for the World Socialists Website

Death rates increased for each quintile as the level of wealth declined.

Itโ€™s at the level of cities and communities โ€œthat the most striking links between inequality and health can be detected,โ€ De Maio wrote. โ€œAt the city level, life expectancy varies from a low of 71.4 years in Gary, Indiana, to a high of 84.7 in Newton, Massachusetts โ€” a gap of more than 13 years.โ€ 

And at the community level, โ€œIn Chicago, there is a nine-year gap between the life expectancy for Black and white people. This gap amounts to more than 3,000 โ€˜excess deathsโ€™โ€ among black Chicagoans, due to โ€œheart disease, cancer, stroke, diabetes and kidney disease. All of these are conditions that an equitable health care system would address,โ€ he concluded.

โ€œThe poorest Americans are also more likely than their rich counterparts to face illness or premature death due to the inherent dangers of low-wage work,โ€ Project Censored noted.

โ€œIn 2019, you no longer have to hang from scaffolding to risk your life on the job,โ€ Marรญa Josรฉ Carmona wrote for Inequality.org. โ€œPrecariousness, stress, and overwork can also make you sick, and even kill you, at a much higher rate than accidents.โ€

She reported on an ILO story that found that less than 14 percent of the 7500 people who die โ€œdue to unsafe and unhealthy working conditions every dayโ€ die from workplace accidents.

The greatest risk comes from โ€œincreasing pressure, precarious contracts, and working hours incompatible with life, which, bit by bit, continue to feed the invisible accident rate that does not appear in the news,โ€ Carmona wrote.  โ€œThe most vulnerable workers are those employed on a temporary or casual basis, those subcontracted through agencies and the false self-employed. ILO data shows the rate of accidents for these employees to be much higher than for any others.โ€

As of May 2020, Project Censored has not been able to identify any corporate news coverage on the GAO or Census Bureau reports on inequality and premature mortality, or on the ILO report about work-related illnesses, accidents, and deaths that take place when workers are off-duty.

6. Shadow Network of Conservative Outlets Emerges to Exploit Faith in Local News

In late October 2019, Carol Thompson reported in the Lansing State Journal that, โ€œDozens of websites branded as local news outlets launched throughout Michigan this fall โ€ฆ promising local news but also offering political messaging.โ€ The websitesโ€™ โ€˜About usโ€™ sections โ€œsay they are published by Metric Media LLC, a company that aims to fill the โ€˜growing void in local and community news after years of steady disinvestment in local reporting by legacy media.โ€™โ€ Thompson wrote, but it soon emerged that they werenโ€™t filling that void with locally-generated news, and the 40 or so sites Thompson found in Michigan were just the tip of the iceberg.

A follow-up investigation by The Michigan Daily reported that โ€œJust this past week, additional statewide networks of these websites have sprung up in Montana and Iowa,โ€ which was followed by a December 2019 report by the Columbia Journalism Review, revealing a network of 450 websites run by five corporate organizations in twelve states that โ€œmimic the appearance and output of traditional news organizationsโ€ in order to โ€œmanipulate public opinion by exploiting faith in local media.โ€ 

All were associated with conservative businessman Brian Timpone.

โ€œIn 2012, Timponeโ€™s company Journatic, an outlet known for its low-cost automated story generation, which became known as โ€˜pink slime journalism,โ€™ attracted national attention and outrage for faking bylines and quotes, and for plagiarism,โ€ CJRโ€™s Priyanjana Bengani reported. Journatic was later rebranded as Locality Labs, whose content ran on the Metric Media websites.

โ€œThe different websites are nearly indistinguishable, sharing identical stories and using regional titles,โ€ Michigan Daily reported. โ€œThe only articles with named authors contain politically skewed content. The rest of the articles on the sites are primarily composed of press releases from local organizations and articles written by the Local Labs News Service.โ€

โ€œDespite the different organization and network names, it is evident these sites are connected,โ€ Bengani wrote. โ€œOther than simply sharing network metadata as described above, they also share bylines (including โ€˜Metric Media News Serviceโ€™ and โ€˜Local Labs News Serviceโ€™ for templated stories), servers, layouts, and templates.โ€

Using a suite of investigative tools, CJR was able to identify at least 189 sites in 10 states run by Metric Media โ€” all created in 2019 โ€” along with 179 run by Franklin Archer (with Timponeโ€™s brother Michael as CEO).

โ€œWe tapped into the RSS feeds of these 189 Metric Media sites,โ€ over a period of two weeks, Bengani wrote, โ€œand found over fifteen thousand unique stories had been published (over fifty thousand when aggregated across the sites), but only about a hundred titles had the bylines of human reporters.โ€ Thatโ€™s well below 1% with a bylineโ€”much less being local. โ€œThe rest cited automated services or press releases.โ€ 

Although The New York Times did publish an article in October 2019 that credited the Lansing State Journal with breaking the story about pseudo-local news organizations, Project Censored notes that, โ€œCorporate coverage has been lackingโ€ฆ. The Columbia Journalism Reviewโ€™s piece expands on the breadth and scope of previous coverage, but its findings do not appear to have been reported by any of the major establishment news outlets.โ€

7. Underreporting of Missing and Victimized Black Women and Girls

Black women and girls go missing in the United States at a higher rate than that of their white counterยญparts. And, that very fact goes missing, too.

โ€œA 2010 study about the media coverage of missing children in the United States discovered that only 20% of reported stories focused on missing Black children despite it corresponding to 33 % of the overall missing children cases,โ€ Carma Henry reported for the Westside Gazette in February 2019.  

But itโ€™s only getting worse. 

โ€œA 2015 study discussed in the William & Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice found that the disparity listed in the 2010 study between the reportage and the reality of missing Black children had increased substantially,โ€ Project Censored noted: 35% of missing children cases vs. just 7% of media stories.

That discussion appeared in a paper that made two other pertinent points. First, that Black criminal perpetrators are over-represented in the media, while Black victims are underrepresented, and second, that โ€œbecause racial minorities are identified as criminals more often than not, non-minorities develop limited empathy toward racial minorities who are often perceived as offenders.โ€ 

Non-minorities in the media are obviously not exempt.

โ€œMedia coverage is often vital in missing person cases because it raises community awareness and can drive funding and search efforts that support finding those missing persons,โ€ Project Censored noted. 

While there is some coverage from small independent sources, โ€œthis gap in coverage of missing Black women and girls has gone widely underreported,โ€ Project Censored noted.

It cited two exceptions (one from ABC News, another from CNN).

 โ€œBut, broadly, US corporate media are not willing to discuss their own shortcomings or to acknowledge the responsibilities they neglect by failing to provide coverage on the search for missing and vicยญtimized Black women and girls.โ€

8. The Public Banking Revolution

The year 2019 marked the 100th anniversary of the USAโ€™s first publicly-owned state bank, the Bank of North Dakota (BND), and in October, California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed the Public Banking Act, authorizing up to 10 similar such banks to be created by Californiaโ€™s city and county governments. In response, the cities of San Francisco and Los Angeles both announced plans to do so. It was the culmination of a decade-long effort that began in the wake of the Great Recession thatโ€™s also been taken up in nearly two dozen other states. Beyond the benefits North Dakota has reaped in the past, such banks could have greatly assisted in responding to COVID-19โ€™s economic devastation, and could yet help fund a just transition to a decarbonized future, along the lines of a Green New Deal.

Yet, despite Californiaโ€™s agenda-setting reputation, Project Censored notes that, โ€œNo major corporate media outlets appear to have devoted recent coverage to this important and timely topic.โ€

โ€œThe Bank of North Dakota was founded in 1919 in response to a farmersโ€™ revolt against out-of-state banks that were foreclosing unfairly on their farms,โ€ Ellen Brown, founder of the Public Banking Institute wrote for Common Dreams. โ€œSince then it has evolved into a $7.4 billion bank that is reported to be even more profitable than JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs, although its mandate is not actually to make a profit but simply to serve the interests of local North Dakota communities.โ€

โ€œThe state of North Dakota has six times as many financial institutions per capita as the rest of the country and itโ€™s because they have the Bank of North Dakota,โ€ Sushil Jacob, an attorney who works with the California Public Banking Alliance told The Guardian. โ€œWhen the great recession hit, the Bank of North Dakota stepped in and provided loans and allowed local banks to thrive.โ€

As a result, โ€œNorth Dakota was the only state that escaped the credit crisis,โ€ Brown told Ananya Garg, reporting for Yes! magazine. โ€œIt never went in the red, [had] the lowest unemployment rate in the country, the lowest foreclosure rate at that time.โ€

In short, โ€œFrom efforts to divest public employee pension funds from the fossil fuel industry and private prisons, to funding the proposed Green New Deal, and counteracting the massive, rapid shutdown of the economy caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, public banking has never seemed more relevant,โ€ Project Censored wrote. 

Itโ€™s a time-tested practical solution the corporate media refuses to discuss.

9. Rising Risks of Nuclear Power Due to Climate Change

As early as 2003, 30 nuclear units were either shut down or reduced power output during a deadly European summer heatwave in Europe. 

But almost two decades later, the corporate media has yet to grasp that โ€œNuclear power plants are unprepared for climate change,โ€ as Project Censored notes. โ€œRising sea levels and warmer waters will impact power plantsโ€™ infrastructure, posing increased risks of nuclear disasters, according to reports from the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and Truthout from September 2019,โ€ they explain. Yet, โ€œTracking back to 2013, corporate news media have only sporadically addressed the potential for climate change to impact nuclear power plants.โ€

Sea level rise โ€” combined with storm surges โ€” represents the most serious threat. That was the focus of a 2018 report by John Vidal from Ensia, a solutions-focused media outlet, which found that โ€œat least 100 U.S., European and Asian nuclear power stations built just a few meters above sea level could be threatened by serious flooding caused by accelerating sea-level rise and more frequent storm surges.โ€ 

โ€œNuclear stations are on the front line of climate change impacts both figuratively and quite literally,โ€ leading climate scientist Michael Mann told Vidal. โ€œWe are likely profoundly underestimating climate change risk and damages in coastal areas.โ€

10. Revive Journalism with a Stimulus Package and Public Option

In late March, Congress passed and President Trump signed a $2.2 trillion coronavirus rescue package, including direct payments of $1,200 per adult and more than $500 billion for large corporations. Before passage, Craig Aaron, the president of Free Press, argued that a stimulus package for journalism was also urgently needed. โ€œIn the face of this panยญdemic, the public needs good, economically secure journalists more than ever,โ€ separating fact from fiction, and holding politicians and powerful institutions accountable,โ€ Aaron wrote in the Columbia Journalism Review.

Aaronโ€™s organization, Free Press, placed journalismโ€™s needs at $5 billion in immediate emergency funds, โ€œless than half of one percent of a trillion-dollar recovery packageโ€ and asked that โ€œCongress put a foundation in place to help sustain journalism over the long term.โ€

Arguing that a โ€œresilient and community-centered media systemโ€ is necessary to get through the pandemic, Aaron concluded, โ€œNow is the time to act. We need sigยญnificant public investments in all corners of the economy, and journalism is no exception.โ€

In an article in Jacobin, Media scholar Victor Pickard advanced a more robust proposal, for $30 billion annually (less than 1.4% of the coronavirus stimulus package, Project Censored noted).  

โ€œWhile corporate news outlets have reported the ongoing demise of newspapers and especially local news sources, they have rarely covered proposals such as Aaronโ€™s and Pickardโ€™s to revitalize journalism through public funding,โ€ Project Censored wrote.


Paul Rosenberg is an activist turned journalist who has written for the Christian Science Monitor, the Los Angeles Times, the Denver Post, Al Jazeera English, Salon.com, and numerous other periodicals. He has also written more than 300 book reviews. He has worked as an editor at Random Lengths News since 2002.

Letters to the Editor: More โ€˜Apocalypse Cowโ€™ Kudos

Kudos to the Bohemian/Pacific Sun for a fantastic piece of journalism. Peter Byrneโ€™s โ€œApocalypse Cowโ€ (Dec. 9) was the most comprehensive story Iโ€™ve read about the plight of the elk and of Point Reyes National Seashore in the face of unrelenting misinformation and negligence by agencies in charge and by our local elected representatives.

I applaud your paper for being bold enough to report the truth regarding the Park Serviceโ€™s failure to follow National Park mandates and National Seashore law which require them to protect and preserve our natural spaces, water quality and wildlife, including threatened and endangered species. 

Byrne also points out the hypocrisy of Huffman declaring himself an environmental advocate while he takes campaign money from organizations which make a profit from the destruction of forests and public lands, and contribute to a decline in air quality, and promote unhealthy forms of food and drink. He has been an unapologetic supporter of the dairy industry even with thousands of public comments calling for a look at the obvious destruction of these national parklands which taxpayers continue to subsidize.

Your kind of honest reporting is critical now when businesses and organizations engage in greenwashing to lull the public into complacency, and the voices of corporate media try to obscure science and drown out those who speak up for a just and sustainable world. Keep up the great work!

Linda Swartz

Cazadero

Open Mic: Prop Problems

By Iain Burnett

Proposition 13, passed in 1978, is eating California alive.

Economists argue that property taxes are the only moral tax. Common land and resources are privatized, and in return, neighbors are compensated with alternative valueโ€”namely, public services and infrastructure. For industrial properties the relationship is more complex; some jobs are created, but the community faces more noise, pollution and traffic.

While there was merit to stabilizing property taxes, Prop. 13 was poorly crafted and sacrificed our stateโ€™s future.

For homeowners, it incentivized something like hoarding. Once upon a time, people downsized and moved away from jobs and schools at retirement, but Prop. 13 broke that cycle. Now renting is more profitable than selling, and only the wealthiest can afford what houses are available. 

Young families struggle here, cannot save enough to compete with all cash offers and then move away with nothing to show. Industries rarely move anyways, and Prop. 13 disincentivized improving or expanding for fear of triggering reappraisal.

Even worse, Prop. 13 limited increases to 2 percent annually. In plain dollars, what has that cost us?

One hundred dollars of property taxes assessed in 1978 provides a maximum revenue of $230 now. Over the same years, inflation raised the cost of goods 4x, and average salaries rose 5x. Had taxes risen with comparable sales values each year ($100 up to $995), local budgets would be in the green and California could have afforded to drop either income or sales tax, both of which impact poor more than rich.

In 2019, property taxes only provided an eighth of California county revenues, while half of county budgets came from state and federal sources. Follow the money, find the power. With so few dollars to go around, budgets get squeezed. Service cuts? School closures? Underwhelming infrastructure? All sprang from Prop. 13.

You think this is a progressive state? Prop. 13 drove a wedge into our society, one that favored businesses, the wealthy and homeowners already established pre-1978. Proponents scared you into thinking grandma would be thrown out; instead, it was the grandkids. 

Letโ€™s kill Prop. 13 so all of California may thrive.

Iain Burnett lives with his wife and daughter in Forestville. To have your topical essay of 350 words considered for publication, write op*****@******an.com.

Left Edge Theatre Premieres Online Festival in 2021

Since its inception, Left Edge Theatre in Sonoma County has always been about innovation, so it’s no surprise that the theater company was one of the first in the North Bay to transition to online programming in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic that made social gatherings impossible.

As early as April 2020, Left Edge was offering streaming productions of past plays, and new works soon followed, including an online season showcase that ran in May of 2020 and a full season of streaming productions that began in September.

Also in September, Left Edge Theatre put out a world-wide call to playwrights to submit previously unpublished short works of theatre, written specifically to be produced remotely for an online audience. Nearly 200 submissions came in, and the Left Edge staff selected 12 plays to produce for the upcoming Hindsight 2021 online festival featuring performances that will stream Jan. 8 to 17 and be available for on-demand viewing Jan. 18 to 31.

With scripts that come from as far away as Australia and as close to home as Sebastopol, the Hindsight 2021 festival will present its 12 plays in four different episodic groupings for online viewing.

The first group features โ€œComedies About Technology,โ€ with three plays that directly reference the ongoing switch to virtual living that began at the pandemicโ€™s outbreak in March 2020.

โ€œGet Sexy on Zoom,โ€ by Andrea Aptecker, concerns two single parents who  meet on Zoom during a pandemic. But their meeting, which begins as a fun, flirty Zoom chat, devolves into malaise. โ€œVirtual Happy Hour,โ€ by Richard Castle, focuses on technophobe Pam; who is horrified when her best friend brings a digital date to her weekly online happy hour. โ€œAlexa the Liar,โ€ Liar by Guy Newsham, follows a single man who engages his smart speaker to help him find love and gain a promotion.

There is also a group of comedic plays that covers a broader range of subjects like โ€œNo Regrets,โ€ by John Minigan, which offers a battle of wits over voicemail; โ€œSurfโ€™s Up,โ€ by Ken Levine, about a father-daughter duo who shake off their button-down life for an โ€˜endless summerโ€™ adventure; and โ€œAn Interview with a George,โ€ by Greg Vovos, about two people on opposite sides of a video job interview.

The other two groupings of short plays includes a selection of three dramas and a selection of three mystery, suspense and fantasy plays. All told, the Hindsight 2021 festival features the work of directors Cindy Brillhart-True, Denise Elia-Yen, Serena Elize Flores, Felicia Freitas, Paige Picard, Argo Thompson, Lulu Thompsxn, Joe Winkler, and David Yen, as well as a cast of over 20 actors performing these 12 works.

The groupings will stream in alternating pairs during evening and matinee performances happening between Friday, Jan. 8 and Sunday, Jan 17. ย Single night streams will be available for $15, and an all-access pass to all streaming performances is only $30. The performances will then be available on-demand for $10 until the end of the month.

For more info and tickets, visit leftedgetheatre.com/hindsight2021.

Sonoma County Human Race Cancels 2021 Event

Each year, communities across the country gather together to run for a good cause in the annual Human Race. No Human Race event is bigger or more popular than the Sonoma County Human Race, which collaboratively raises funds for several local nonprofits while offering the public a fun community outing that includes a 3K and 10K walk and run, a festival area called the Marketplace and a pancake breakfast.

Like other social gatherings, the Sonoma County Human Race was forced to cancel its in-person event last May due to the Covid-19 pandemic, and with the continued concern for the health and safety of the community, the Center for Volunteer & Nonprofit Leadership (CVNL)โ€“which hosts the eventโ€“ has made the difficult decision not to hold the Sonoma County Human Race in 2021 either.

โ€œNonprofits that have raised funds over the course of the eventโ€™s history have had to learn new ways to meet their fundraising goals in 2020,โ€ says Dawn Bell, Special Events Coordinator at CVNL, in a statement. โ€œTo help support them, CVNL will continue to share resources and develop training around online fundraising and virtual event production. We appreciate everything that nonprofits are doing: together we can help our communities stay safe, informed, and connected.โ€

After canceling 2020’s Human Race, CVNL quickly pivoted to a virtual format for its ongoing work in supporting nonprofits. For the past 10 months, CVNL has been working in the hope that the 2021 event would be the biggest and best in its 40-year history, though it needs help to do so. The public is invited to learn ho to volunteer time and donate funds to the center, and local nonprofits are encouraged to visit CVNL’s extensive resource library and check out it’s professional development workshops.

In addition to providing resources, training, and other services to support nonprofits in Sonoma County and beyond, CVNL is busy in the disaster recovery world. In Sonoma, Marin, Solano, and Napa Counties, CVNL operates Emergency Volunteer Centers, working with government and nonprofit agencies to gather and assess community needs on an ongoing basis when a disasters strike. Their role is to oversee and manage spontaneous volunteers and physical and monetary donations, distributing them to nonprofit agencies helping individuals directly affected.

CVNLโ€™s current goal is to relaunch the Sonoma County Human Race in 2022 with a community of nonprofits, businesses, and individual fundraisers who will once again come together to run, walk, or roll in the popular and meaningful event.

Letters to the Editor: No Butts

In the midst of so much disease and uncertainty, there is something that individuals can do to improve their own well-being, as well as their communityโ€™s health. There is no better time to quit smoking or vaping tobacco (or other substances) than during this pandemic. Studies show that smoking and vaping compromise the immune system and weaken the lungsโ€™ defenses....

Popular Family Series Returns For Virtual Season of Shows

Back when social gatherings were possible, the Luther Burbank Center for the Arts in Santa Rosa hosted world-class performers and artists as well as nationally-recognized education programs and popular community events such as the Clover Sonoma Family Fun Series. This year, as Covid-19 keeps forcing live events to go online, Luther Burbank Center for the Arts continues to host events...

How Bay Area Food Banks are Coping with the Pandemicโ€™s Hunger Crisis

San Francisco-Marin Food Bank volunteers
Second Harvest Food Bank Development and Marketing Officer Suzanne Willis remembers when her Watsonville-based food pantry served about 55,000 people monthly, providing them with parcels of fresh produce and pantry staples.  This was early in 2020, before the Covid-19 pandemic hit, prompting widespread business closures in March. After that, the number climbed to approximately 88,000โ€”an increase of 60 percent. Part of...

Sonoma County Regional Parks Takes Ownership of 335-Acre Ranch Property

Carrington Ranch Sonoma County Parks
Ownership of the 335-acre Carrington Coast Ranch north of Bodega Bay near Salmon Creek was conveyed to the county parks agency last week.

New Year Opens with Several Online North Bay Events

Even though 2020 is officially done and the New Year is here, the Covid-19 pandemic continues to make in-person gatherings a tricky endeavor in the North Bay. To help start 2021 in a positive way, several local events boasting music, art, history, poetry and other timely communal interests are happening online this week. Hereโ€™s a round up of whatโ€™s...

‘Project Censored’ Spotlights 2020’s Buried News Stories

Project Censored 2020 Sonoma State
Project Censored sheds light on the most significant news that was somehow deemed not fit to print with an annual book.

Letters to the Editor: More โ€˜Apocalypse Cowโ€™ Kudos

Kudos to the Bohemian/Pacific Sun for a fantastic piece of journalism. Peter Byrneโ€™s โ€œApocalypse Cowโ€ (Dec. 9) was the most comprehensive story Iโ€™ve read about the plight of the elk and of Point Reyes National Seashore in the face of unrelenting misinformation and negligence by agencies in charge and by our local elected representatives. I applaud your paper for being...

Open Mic: Prop Problems

Microphone - Kane Reinholdtsen/Unsplash
By Iain Burnett Proposition 13, passed in 1978, is eating California alive. Economists argue that property taxes are the only moral tax. Common land and resources are privatized, and in return, neighbors are compensated with alternative valueโ€”namely, public services and infrastructure. For industrial properties the relationship is more complex; some jobs are created, but the community faces more noise, pollution and...

Left Edge Theatre Premieres Online Festival in 2021

Since its inception, Left Edge Theatre in Sonoma County has always been about innovation, so it's no surprise that the theater company was one of the first in the North Bay to transition to online programming in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic that made social gatherings impossible. As early as April 2020, Left Edge was offering streaming productions of...

Sonoma County Human Race Cancels 2021 Event

Each year, communities across the country gather together to run for a good cause in the annual Human Race. No Human Race event is bigger or more popular than the Sonoma County Human Race, which collaboratively raises funds for several local nonprofits while offering the public a fun community outing that includes a 3K and 10K walk and run,...
11,084FansLike
4,606FollowersFollow
6,928FollowersFollow