The Byrne Report

September 5-11, 2007

Despite—or perhaps because of—the fact that nationalist Iraqi militias have largely defeated the American invasion of their country, ordinary Americans who have silently opposed the war remain quiet. With the exception of a few groups, notably Code Pink, the peace movement has been missing in action for four years. And that is one reason why Bush can issue blatantly ridiculous statements, such as that withdrawing from Vietnam 30 years ago created a bad military and political precedent for today, without losing his job. There is nothing like several million angry demonstrators on the Mall to make politicians and the bankers who love them look for the nearest way out of a war.

In the absence of people power, we have pundit power. Meet Max Boot, roving columnist for the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times and the Weekly Standard. Boot’s specialty is rewriting history so that the corporativized thugs we call our government can continue to murder entire populations under the aegis of protecting their “freedom.” In an Aug. 24 article (“Another Vietnam?”) for the Wall Street Journal, Boot cited the “killing fields” of Cambodia as a cost of withdrawing from Vietnam. What he failed to note is that those “killing fields” were directly caused by American carpet-bombing of Cambodia’s agriculture infrastructure. We deliberately caused a countrywide famine that empowered the Khmer Rouge.

But even the Khmer Rouge were not as malicious as the American-created death squads (the CIA’s Phoenix Program targeting civilians) that systematically assassinated 26,000 South Vietnamese dissidents. Ultimately, it was the Vietnamese people who saved the Cambodian people from starvation and chaos. Those same Vietnamese freedom fighters had defeated a high-tech army of American invaders who killed more than 5 million people while Halliburton (then called Brown & Root) piled up war profits.

Boot also fails to mention other circumstances that contributed to America’s military defeat in Southeast Asia. As the American death toll passed 50,000, people of all ages and classes momentarily united with the Vietnamese people, finally disgusted by the unjust war. In Iraq, the number of exploded GI’s has yet to reached the level of critical mass necessary for American consumers to take to the streets in anger.

While we Americans occupy ourselves eating sugary trash, scarfing Adderall and obsessing about sex and fame, several million Iraqis have lost their lives to a brutalizing occupation, two bloody invasions and 12 years of incessant bombing coupled with a cruel economic blockade that turned the technologically and sociologically advanced Iraq into a rubble patrolled by reactionary religios and corporate war-profiteers.

What can we do? Take a real lesson from Vietnam. Years ago, after images of napalmed Vietnamese children surfaced in the media, many Americans extended their hands to the Vietnamese in friendship and repentance and antiwar fervor. In June 2004, after Nadia McCaffrey’s son Patrick, a National Guardsman based in Sonoma County, was killed in Iraq, she traveled there to meet with the mothers of Iraqis killed by Americans. The video of that moving encounter between fellow sufferers, Journey to Peace, shows the possibility of forging Iraqi-American friendships.

Two weeks ago, McCaffrey and the Farmer-Veteran Coalition held a public meeting at the Elim Lutheran Church in Petaluma to encourage Iraq war vets to take up farming. Sonoma County organizations represented at the sparsely attended meeting were Farms Not Arms and California Farm Link. McCaffrey, who has been an outspoken critic of the Iraq war, told me she is now “disgusted” with the peace movement and the hidden agendas of some of its organizing forces. Therefore, she is working “nonpolitically,” she says, to build Veteran’s Village, an organic farm where vets can reintegrate into society.

Next month, McCaffrey and the nonpolitical coalition are taking their community organizing effort to New York City, hoping to reach out to all vets, including the pro-war ones. I find this retreat from political action to be disappointing.

The problems of invader-returnees are miniscule compared to the pain we inflict upon the Iraqi people. If remorseful vets want to make reparations for the evil that they—and we collectively—have done to Iraq, they and we must actively and loudly oppose the war, not retreat into farms and “nonpolitical” silence. Rather, we must vociferously demand the immediate withdrawal of American troops and war-profiteering corporations from Iraq. In four years of war and occupation, very few Americans have reached out to the suffering people whose country we are so blithely destroying. Do we dare to create an Iraqi-American friendship movement?

That kind of political courage would make Bush and his Boot-licker quake.

or


Winery profile: Go West, young drinker

0

You’ve heard more than once that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger rejected Zinfandel boosters’ hopes for an official heritage grape proclamation. Perhaps you’ve even read the proper noun “Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger” more than enough. But the Governator has agreed to pump up California wine in general, proclaiming September to be “California Wine Month” for the third consecutive year. He “applauds California vintners and winegrape growers,” and retailers and restaurant chains like Safeway, BevMo and Trader Vic’s pile on to highlight California’s status as a churner-out-er of a stupendous quantity of wine. (It’s at least worthwhile to Google Schwarzenegger’s action-photo from last year’s press release, in which he appears to be pressing a few reps with a seriously outsized wine bottle.)

What can one do to celebrate, here, in the absence of aP.F. Chang’s, where it’s Wine Month all year long? Gas up the Hummer, take a joyride to the far-flung reaches of what this great state has to offer. Go big, head north. Go, in fact, to Cloverdale.

If you haven’t been to Cloverdale recently, there have been some changes since the Highway 101 bypass sent the faded citrus queen into a predictable funk. They’re spiffing it up, getting it noticed. The town’s new motto could well be “We’re Here.” Actually, it’s “Where the Vineyards Meet the Redwoods,” but I like “Cloverdale, It’s on the Way.” On the way to where? Mendocino, for the most part. First Street Wines kicked off a brand-new tasting room in July. It’s half a block off of the main street, a cooperative of two family wineries, serving Hart’s Desire Wines and Pendleton Estate Wines in an art gallery setting. Besides the requisite minimum of vineyard art, a variety of styles are represented so that even the jaded big-town elitist may soften to at least one piece.

Hart’s Desire continues on in an artistic, lust-for-life bent, the label art featuring a rotating cast of women with come-hither eyes. John Hart makes a fine 2006 Russian River Valley Chardonnay ($24), light in oak with butterscotch and lemon-butter notes. His 2005 Sonoma Coast “Rocking H Ranch” Syrah ($24) is full and juicy, with something ineffable on the palate’s horizon, like the deep warm glow of a long day’s end. Pendleton’s 2005 Ponzo Vineyard Petite Sirah ($33) is a blend with Zin, while the remaining Petite finds a home in the 2005 Ponzo Vineyard Zinfandel ($27): fragrant deep berries, and jammy and substantial, respectively.

While you’re up that way, why not turn west on Highway 128 and see what’s been going on in Anderson Valley for the past 30-plus years? Find wines such as earthy Pinot at Husch (4400 Hwy. 128, Philo; 1.800.55.HUSCH) and Riesling at Greenwood Ridge (5501 Hwy. 128, Philo; 707.895.2002). At Esterlina (1200 Holmes Ranch Road, Philo; 707.895.2920)—one of California’s premiere family-owned African-American wineries—one can be seated on a deck overlooking the valley, leisurely enjoying flights of wine and Cheetos. Start with brunch at the Boonville General Store

(17810-B Hwy. 128; 707.895.9477). The young couple who own this funky cafe are passionate about preparing an all-organic menu of breakfast and lunch items, and it’s populated with Boonville’s most cosmopolitan locals. And take the biodiesel Hummer.

First Street Wines

Address: 105 E. First St., Cloverdale.

Phone: 707.894.4410

Open Friday–Saturday, 11am to 6 pm; Sunday, 11am to 5pm.

No tasting fee.



SEARCH AVAILABLE RESERVATIONS & BOOK A TABLE

View All


Quick dining snapshots by Bohemian staffers.


Winery news and reviews.


Food-related comings and goings, openings and closings, and other essays for those who love the kitchen and what it produces.


Recipes for food that you can actually make.

Stage review: ‘The Clean House’ at Cinnabar

0

the arts | stage |

Photograph by Jeff Thomas
Couch Apple: Danielle Thys portrays Lane,a wife who gets dumped.

By David Templeton

Ice cream is what God eats when he’s tired. It is better to die standing up than lying down. The perfect joke makes you forget about your life, and can best be described as being somewhere between an angel and a fart. These are just a few of the many unexpected and delightful revelations in Sarah Ruhl’s delicious 2004 Pulitzer-nominated play The Clean House, a comedy-drama that is so fresh and funny and creative and moving, it seems impossible that I’ve never heard of it until now.

With Cinnabar Theater’s pitch-perfect new production, solidly directed by actress Tara Blau, Cinnabar launches its new season with a big, beautiful bang, assembling a first-rate cast to populate Ruhl’s clever exploration of love, death, laughter and housecleaning. Inventively structured and packed with surprises, the play blends magical realism and dreamlike passages with dialogue that is simultaneously fresh, coarse, inspiring and amusing.

Lane (Danielle Thys) is a brilliant surgeon with two major problems, one she knows about and one of which she is not yet aware. As she states in her opening monologue, “My cleaning lady got depressed and stopped cleaning my house. I was, like, clean my house!” That’s problem number one. Number two, her lost-boy surgeon husband, Charles (Tim Kniffin), is about to leave her for a much older woman, a 62-year-old Argentinean mastectomy patient named Anna (Linda Ayres-Frederick), which will lead to twists that will make the whole clean-house thing moot.

But first, the housecleaner, Matilde (Juliet Tanner)—who would rather think up jokes in Spanish than clean house—will hire Lane’s neurotic, cleaning-fetish sister Virginia (Laura Jorgensen) to secretly clean the house in her stead, an arrangement that allows Virginia to burn off some pent-up frustrations, while giving Matilde time to daydream about her gag-loving mother and father, one of whom, we learn, actually died laughing. That notion of dying while laughing is central to Ruhl’s play, which consistently presents tragic or life-changing events in funny ways. There is so much wisdom and beauty in this script, one could imagine it becoming the source text for a new religion, one that puts laughter and kindness and an appetite for life on the altar instead of fear and dogma and strict adherence to the rules.

The beauty of Ruhl’s writing lies in the way she fits breathtaking ideas and phrases into otherwise straightforward moments, as in Virginia’s description of cleaning her home, filled with mentions of “tucking” household items away for the night and singing lullabies. On one hand, it’s pleasant dialogue, but on a deeper level, we see how Virginia has come to use cleaning as a substitute for raising children, which she wanted but never had.

Similarly, when a love-struck Charles attempts to justify his affair with Anna by borrowing concepts from Jewish mysticism, describing it as his sacred Jewish responsibility to leave Lane now that he’s found his soul mate (“You’re not Jewish,” Lane reminds him), it is both funny and heartbreaking on several levels at once.

The cast is impeccable, zigging easily from one-liners and comic collisions to some very difficult emotional moments, literally causing the audience to laugh and cry at the same time. Kniffin is given the most to do physically, from a remarkable pantomimed breast-cancer surgery to a trip through a now-filled Alaska in search of a tree to heal an ailing Anna, all performed with few props and yet perfectly realized. As Anna, Ayres-Frederick is believably ecstatic at finding love in the midst of fighting cancer, and is astonishingly detailed in the subsequent physical deterioration.

Tanner, as the matter-of-fact Matilde, is frequently mesmerizing, tossing off her lines with a sense of pleasure and delight that is infectious. And as the two sisters, Lane and Virginia, Thys and Jorgensen are remarkable, imbuing their characters’ emotional arcs with crystal-clear moments of realization and self-awareness as they learn what Anna and Virginia have always known—that life is not organized and cannot be planned out, that life is often at its best when it’s at its messiest.

‘The Clean House’ runs through Sept. 22.

Friday–Saturday and Sept. 20 at 8pm; Sept. 9 and 16 at 2pm.

Cinnabar Theater, 3333 Petaluma Blvd. N., Petaluma.

$20–$22.

707.763.8920.



View All


Museums and gallery notes.


Reviews of new book releases.


Reviews and previews of new plays, operas and symphony performances.


Reviews and previews of new dance performances and events.

Project Censored

0

Photograph by Edward Troxell

Axis of Evil ‘R’ Us : Oppression of the weak, from women to children to religious separatists, is a hallmark of this year’s crop of unerreported stories. Wherever there’s evil, seemingly there’s G.W. Bush.

By Tricia Boreta, Peter Phillips, Kate Sims, Andrew Roth and Project Censored

The systemic erosion of human rights and civil liberties, in both the United States and the world, is the common theme of the most censored stories for the 2008 volume. The continuing consolidation of private for-profit bureaucracies with public governmental entities is nothing less than the diminishment of personal freedoms for all persons. By supporting independent media, a free Internet, transparent government, participatory decision making, and by upholding our core values of due process and human rights, we can stand with our neighbors, friends and communities to build a better tomorrow. Please share these stories with others, and keep yourselves informed and active.–Peter Phillips, Project Censored

The oldest human right defined in the history of English-speaking civilization is the right to challenge governmental power of arrest and detention through the use of habeas corpus laws, considered to be the most critical parts of the Magna Carta, signed by King John in 1215.

With the approval of Congress and no outcry from corporate media, the Military Commissions Act of 2006 (MCA) signed by President Bush on Oct. 17, 2006, ushered in military commission law for U.S. citizens and noncitizens alike. The MCA effectively does away with habeas corpus rights for “any person” arbitrarily deemed to be an “enemy of the state.” The judgment on who is deemed an “enemy combatant” is solely at the discretion of President Bush.

Besides allowing “any person” to be swallowed up by the prison system, the law prohibits detainees once inside from appealing to the traditional American courts until after prosecution and sentencing, which could translate into an indefinite imprisonment since there are no timetables for the current tribunal process to play out.

On June 8, 2007, the Senate Judiciary Committee passed the Habeas Corpus Restoration Act on an 11 to 8 vote. The bipartisan bill, authored by Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont and Sen. Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania, will restore habeas rights that were taken away last year by the Military Commissions Act. The bill moved to the full Senate June 26, and its vote is still pending.

Sources: Robert Parry: “Who Is ‘Any Person’ in Tribunal Law?” Consortium, Oct. 19, 2006; “Still No Habeas Rights for You,” Consortium, Feb. 3, 2007. Also, “Repeal the Military Commissions Act and Restore the Most American Human Right,” by Thom Hartmann, Common Dreams, Feb. 2, 2007.

2. Bush Moves Toward Martial Law

The John Warner National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) of 2007, which was quietly signed by Bush on Oct. 17, 2006—the very same day that he signed the Military Commissions Act, above—allows the president to station military troops anywhere in the United States and take control of state-based National Guard units without the consent of the governor or local authorities, in order to “suppress public disorder.”

By revising the two-centuries-old Insurrection Act, the law in effect repeals the Posse Comitatus Act, which placed strict prohibitions on military involvement in domestic law enforcement. As the only U.S. criminal statute that outlaws military operations directed against the American people, it has been our best protection against tyranny enforced by martial law, the harsh system of rules that takes effect when the military takes control of the normal administration of justice.

The massive NDAA grants the Pentagon $532.8 billion to include implementation of the new law, which furthermore facilitates militarized police roundups of protesters, so called illegal aliens, potential terrorists and other “undesirables” for detention in facilities already contracted and under construction, and the transferring from the Pentagon to local police units the latest technology and weaponry designed to suppress dissent.

Source: “Bush Moves Toward Martial Law” by Frank Morales. Uruknet.info, Oct. 26, 2006.

3. U.S. Control of Africa’s Resources

U.S. Department of Energy data shows that the United States now imports more oil from the continent of Africa than from the country of Saudi Arabia. In February 2007, the White House announced the formation of the United States Africa Command (AFRICOM), a new unified Pentagon command center in Africa to be established by September 2008. This military penetration of Africa is being presented as a humanitarian guard in the global war on terror. The real objective, however, is the procurement and control of Africa’s oil and its global delivery systems.

People native to the Niger Delta region have not benefited, but rather suffered, as a result of sitting on top of vast natural oil and gas deposits. Environmental and human rights activists have, for years, documented atrocities on the part of oil companies and the military in this region. As the tactics of resistance groups have shifted from petition and protest to more proactive measures, attacks on pipelines and oil facilities have curtailed the flow of oil leaving the region. As a Center for International Policy report puts it, “Within the first six months of 2006, there were 19 attacks on foreign oil operations and over $2.187 billion lost in oil revenues; the Department of Petroleum Resources claims this figure represents 32 percent of ‘the revenue the country [Nigeria] generated this year.'”

Oil companies and the Pentagon are attempting to link these resistance groups to international terror networks in order to legitimize the use of the U.S. military to “stabilize” these areas and secure the energy flow. No evidence has been found to link the Niger Delta resistance groups to international terror networks or jihadists.

Source: “Understanding AFRICOM” by Bryan Hunt. MoonOfAlabama.org, Feb. 21, 2007.

4. Destructive Free Trade Agreements

The March 2007 Oxfam report, “Signing Away the Future,” reveals that the United States and the European Union are vigorously pursuing increasingly destructive regional and bilateral agreements outside the auspices of the World Trade Organization. These agreements require enormous irreversible concessions from developing countries, while offering almost nothing in return.

The U.S. and E.U. are demanding unprecedented tariff reductions, sometimes to nothing, as the two superpowers dump subsidized agricultural goods on undeveloped countries, plunging local farmers into desperate poverty. Meanwhile, the U.S. and E.U. provide themselves with high tariffs and stringent import quotas to protect their own producers. Unprecedented loss of livelihood, displacement, slave labor, along with spiraling degradation of human rights and environment are resulting as economic governance is forced from governments of developing countries and taken over by unaccountable multinational firms.

The U.S. and E.U. fair trade agreements (FTAs) also require the adoption of plant-breeder rights that remove the right to share seeds among indigenous farmers. The livelihood of the world’s poorest farmers is thus made even more vulnerable, while profit margins of the world’s largest agribusinesses continue to climb. FTAs from the U.S. are now pushing for patents on plants, which will not only limit the rights of farmers to exchange or sell seeds, but also forbid them to save and reuse seed they have grown themselves for generations.

Under other U.S. FTAs, developing-country governments will no longer be able to reject a patent application because a firm fails to indicate the origin of a plant or show proof of consent for its use from a local community. As a result, communities could find themselves forced to pay for patented plant varieties based on genetic resources from their own soil.

Sources: “Signing Away The Future,” Oxfam International, March 2007. “Free Trade Enslaving Poor Countries,” by Sanjay Suri. Inter Press Service, March 20, 2007.

5. Forced Labor Builds U.S. Embassy in Iraq

The enduring monument to U.S. liberation and democracy in Iraq will be the most expensive and heavily fortified embassy in the world. It is being built by a Kuwaiti contractor repeatedly accused of using forced labor trafficked from South Asia under U.S. contracts. The estimated $592 million, 104-acre fortress equal in size to the Vatican City is scheduled to open this month.

With a highly secretive contract awarded by the U.S. State Department, First Kuwaiti General Trading & Contracting has joined the ranks of Halliburton/KBR in Iraq by using bait-and-switch recruiting practices. Thousands of citizens from countries that have banned travel or work in Iraq are being smuggled into brutal and inhumane labor camps, and subjected to months of forced servitude—all in the middle of the U.S.-controlled Green Zone, right under the nose of the U.S. State Department.

Though the Associated Press reports that “the 5,500 Americans and Iraqis working at the embassy are far more numerous than at any other U.S. mission worldwide,” there is no mention in corporate media of the 3,000 South Asian laborers working in dangerous and abysmal living and working conditions—sometimes after being tricked into working in Iraq—that no American worker would tolerate.

On April 4, 2006, the Pentagon issued a contracting directive following an investigation that officially confirmed that contractors in Iraq, many working as subcontractors to Halliburton/KBR, were illegally confiscating worker passports, using deceptive, bait-and-switch hiring practices and charging recruiting fees that indebted low-paid migrant workers for many months or even years to their employers.

The Pentagon has yet to announce, however, any penalty for those found to be in violation of U.S. labor trafficking laws or contract requirements.

Source: “A U.S. Fortress Rises in Baghdad: Asian Workers Trafficked to Build World’s Largest Embassy,” by David Phinney. CorpWatch.org, Oct. 17, 2006.

6. Operation FALCON Raids

Under the code name Operation FALCON (Federal and Local Cops Organized Nationally), three national mass arrests occurred between April 2005 and October 2006. In an unprecedented move, more than 30,000 “fugitives” were arrested in the largest dragnets in the nation’s history. The operations directly involved over 960 state, local and federal agencies and were the brainchild of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and U.S. Marshals director Ben Reyna.

The Department of Justice supplied television networks with government-shot action videotape of marshals and local cops raiding homes and breaking down doors, “targeting the worst of the worst criminals on the run,” with an emphasis on suspected sex offenders. Yet less than 10 percent of the total 30,150 were suspected sex offenders; less than 2 percent owned firearms. To date, the U.S. Marshals office has issued no public statement as to whether the people arrested in Operation FALCON have been processed or released. Is this action a practice roundup in the move toward martial law?

Between April 4 and April 10, 2005, FALCON I swept up 10,340 fugitives in the largest nation-wide mass arrest (to that date) in American history. Operation FALCON II, April 17–23, 2006, arrested another 9,037 individuals from 27 states mostly west of the Mississippi River. Operation FALCON III, Oct. 22–28, 2006, netted another 10,733 fugitives in 24 states east of the Mississippi River.

The U.S. Marshals Service has not yet disclosed the names of the people arrested in these massive sweeps nor what crimes they were accused of. The media appear to have played an essential role in concealing the important details of the operation. Noncritical cookie-cutter articles that appeared in newspapers across the country suggest that the media may have collaborated directly with the Justice Department.

Sources: “Operation Falcon and the Looming Police State” by Mike Whitney. Ukernet.info, Feb. 26, 2007.

7. Behind Blackwater Inc.

The company that most embodies the privatization of the military industrial complex—a primary part of the Project for a New American Century and the neoconservative revolution—is the private security firm Blackwater. Blackwater is the most powerful mercenary firm in the world, with 20,000 soldiers, the world’s largest private military base, a fleet of 20 aircraft, including helicopter gunships, and a private intelligence division. The firm is also manufacturing its own surveillance blimps and target systems. Blackwater is headed by right-wing Christian and ex–Navy Seal Erik Prince, whose family has had deep neoconservative connections.

One of the last things Dick Cheney did before leaving office as Defense Secretary under George H. W. Bush was to commission a Halliburton study on how to privatize the military bureaucracy. That study effectively created the groundwork for a continuing war profiteer bonanza.

Private contractors currently constitute the second-largest force in Iraq. At last count, there were about 100,000 contractors in Iraq, of which 48,000 work as private soldiers, according to a Government Accountability Office report. These soldiers operate with almost no oversight or effective legal constraints and are politically expedient, as contractor deaths go uncounted in the official toll. With Prince calling for the creation of a “contractor brigade” before military audiences, the Bush administration has found a backdoor for engaging in an undeclared expansion of occupation.

Blackwater currently has about 2,300 personnel actively deployed in nine countries and is aggressively expanding its presence inside U.S. borders. They provide the security for U.S. diplomats in Iraq, guarding everyone from Paul Bremer and John Negroponte to the current U.S. ambassador, Zalmay Khalilzad. They’re training troops in Afghanistan and have been active in the Caspian Sea, where they set up a Special Forces base miles from the Iranian border. According to reports, they are currently negotiating directly with the Southern Sudanese regional government to start training the Christian forces of Sudan.

Blackwater’s connections are impressive. Joseph Schmitz, the former Pentagon Inspector General, whose job was to police the war contractor bonanza, has moved on to become the vice chairman of the Prince Group, Blackwater’s parent company, and the general counsel for Blackwater.

Bush recently hired Fred Fielding, Blackwater’s former lawyer, to replace Harriet Miers as his top lawyer; and Ken Starr, the former Whitewater prosecutor who led the impeachment charge against President Clinton, is now Blackwater’s counsel of record and has filed briefs with Supreme Court to fight wrongful death lawsuits brought against Blackwater. Cofer Black, 30-year CIA veteran and former head of CIA’s counterterrorism center, credited with spearheading the extraordinary rendition program after 9-11, is now senior executive at Blackwater and perhaps its most powerful operative.

Sen. John Warner, the former head of the Senate Armed Services Committee, has called Blackwater “our silent partner in the global war on terror.”

Source: “Our Mercenaries in Iraq: Blackwater Inc. and Bush’s Undeclared Surge” by Jeremy Scahill. Democracy Now!, Jan. 26, 2007.

8. KIA: The U.S. Invasion of India

Farmers’ cooperatives in India are defending their nation’s food security and the future of Indian farmers against the neoliberal invasion of genetically modified (GM) seed. As many as 28,000 Indian farmers have committed suicide over the last decade as a result of debt incurred from failed GM crops and competition with subsidized U.S. crops. Yet, when India’s prime minister Manmohan Singh met with President Bush in March 2006 to finalize nuclear agreements, they also signed the Indo-U.S. Knowledge Initiative on Agriculture (KIA), backed by Monsanto, Archer Daniels Midland (ADM) and Wal-Mart.

The KIA allows for the grab of India’s seed sector by Monsanto, of its trade sector by giant agribusiness ADM and Cargill, and its retail sector by Wal-Mart. The KIA impacts 650 million farmers of India and 40 million small retailers, and it is redefining the relationships between people in the two biggest democracies in the world.

KIA has paved the way for Wal-Mart’s plans to open 500 stores in India, the first of which was to have debuted last month, which will compound the outsourcing of India’s food supply and threaten 14 million small family venders with loss of livelihood.

Sources: “Vandana Shiva on Farmer Suicides, the U.S.-India Nuclear Deal, Wal-Mart in India” by Vandana Shiva with Amy Goodman. Democracy Now!, Dec. 13, 2006. “Genetically Modified Seeds: Women in India take on Monsanto” by Arun Shrivastava. Global Research, Oct. 9, 2006.

9. Privatization of U.S. Infrastructure

In 1956, when President Eisenhower signed the Federal-Aid Highway Act, he considered the interstate highway system so vital to the public interest that he authorized the federal government to assume 90 percent of the massive cost.

Now, more than 20 states have enacted legislation allowing public-private partnerships to build and run highways. Investment firms including Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and the Carlyle Group are approaching state politicians with advice to sell off public highway and transportation infrastructure.

Proponents celebrate these transactions as a “no-pain, all-gain” way to off-load maintenance expenses and increase highway-building funds without raising taxes. Opponents are lambasting these plans as a major turn toward handing the nation’s valuable common asset over to private firms whose fidelity is to stockholders.

On June 29, 2006, Indiana’s governor Mitch Daniels announced that Indiana had received $3.8 billion from a foreign consortium made up of the Spanish construction firm Cintra and the Macquarie Infrastructure Group (MIG) of Australia. In exchange, the state handed over operation of a 157-mile Indiana toll road for the next 75 years. With the consortium collecting the tolls, which will eventually rise far higher, the privatized road should generate $11 billion for MIG-Cintra over the course of the contract.

In September 2005, Daniels solicited bids for the project, with Goldman Sachs serving as the state’s financial adviser—a role that netted the bank a $20 million advisory fee. When Goldman Sachs began advising Indiana on selling its toll road, it failed to mention that its Australian subsidiary’s mutual funds were ratcheting up their positions in MIG, becoming de facto investors in the deal.

Despite public concerns, privatization of U.S. transportation infrastructure has the full backing of the Bush administration. Tyler Duvall, the U.S. Department of Transportation’s assistant secretary for transportation policy, says his department has raised the idea with “almost every state” government and is working on sample legislation that states can use for such projects. In Texas, Gov. Rick Perry still refuses to release details of a $1.3 billion contract his administration signed with Cintra for a 40-mile toll road from Austin to Seguin, or of an enormous $184 billion proposal to build a 4,000-mile network of toll roads through Texas.

It is known, however, that the Bush administration is quietly advancing the plan to build a huge 10-lane NAFTA superhighway through the heart of the United States along Interstate 35, from the Mexican border at Laredo, Texas, to the Canadian border north of Duluth, Minn., financed largely through public-private partnerships.

Sources: “The Highwaymen” by Daniel Schulman with James Ridgeway. Mother Jones, February 2007. “Bush Administration Quietly Plans NAFTA Super Highway” by Jerome R. Corsi Human Events, June 12, 2006.

10. Vulture Funds Threaten Debt Relief

Vulture funds are financial organizations that buy up debts that are near default or bankruptcy. The vulture fund pays the original investor pennies on the dollar for the debt and then approaches the debtor to arrange a better repayment on the loan, or goes after the debtor in court.

In the private financial world, these funds, like the birds they are named for, provide a useful function for investors who are unable to follow up on defaulted debts and are themselves facing financial ruin if the debtor reneges entirely.

In the case of nations, the actions of vulture funds are corrupting the process begun in 1996 to provide debt relief for Third World nations struggling to emerge from the heavy debt laid upon them by previous corrupt rulers and colonial masters.

In one recent case, the poverty-stricken nation of Zambia was negotiating with Romania to reduce a $40 million debt still owed from a 1979 loan to buy Romanian tractors. In 1999, Romania had agreed to liquidate the entire loan for $3 million. Zambia planned to use the debt cancellation to invest in much-needed nurses, teachers and basic infrastructure. Just before the deal was finalized however, investors at the England-based vulture fund Donegal International convinced the Romanian government to sell them the loan for just under $4 million, not much more than Zambia had offered. Donegal then turned around and sued Zambia (where the average wage is barely a dollar a day) for the full $40 million.

Throughout the lawsuit, global NGOs have pleaded with the English high court to void the new contract and allow Zambia to honor the original agreement of $3 million. But on Feb. 15, 2007, an English court ruled that Donegal was entitled to much of what it was seeking—at least $15 million, perhaps more.

In a last desperate plea, global NGOs working to relieve Third World debt (such as Oxfam and the Jubilee Debt Campaign) turned to Donegal directly, asking them to forgive the debt. Donegal knows that, as a national entity, even a cash-poor country like Zambia has access to considerable resources; in this case, copper, cobalt, gem stones, coal, uranium, marble and much more. Public works and other civic improvement projects can also be liquidated.

Also, Donegal has no history of mercy toward impoverished nations. In 1996, it paid $11 million for a discounted Peruvian debt and threatened to bankrupt the country unless they paid $58 million. Donegal got its money. Now they’re suing Congo Brazzaville for $400 million for a debt they bought for $10 million. Donegal and other vulture funds have teams of lawyers combing the world for assets that can be seized.

Source: “Vulture Fund Threat to Third World” by Greg Palast with Meirion Jones. BBC Newsnight, Feb. 14, 2007.

Other Headlines That You Never Saw 11. ‘Reconstruction’ in Afghanistan

A report issued in June 2005 by the nonprofit organization Action Aid reveals that much of the U.S. tax money earmarked to rebuild Afghanistan actually ends up going no further than the pockets of wealthy U.S. corporations.

12. Massacre in Haiti by U.N. Troops

President Jean-Bertrand Aristide and his Lavalas political party were ousted from power on Feb. 29, 2004. Eyewitness testimony confirms the killing of some 30 people by U.N. forces in Haiti’s Cité Soleil community on Dec. 22, 2006, reportedly as collective punishment for a massive demonstration in which about 10,000 people rallied against the foreign military occupation of their country.

13. Immigrant Roundups to Gain Cheap Labor for United StatesImmigration law is creating a two-tier society, in which millions of people are denied fundamental rights and social benefits because they are recruited to come to the U.S. by those corporations on visas that condemn them to a second-class status.

14. Impunity for U.S. War Criminals

A provision mysteriously tucked into the Military Commission Act just before it passed through Congress and was signed by President Bush on Oct. 17, 2006 (see Top Ten numbers 1 and 2), redefines torture, removing the harshest, most controversial techniques from the definition of war crimes, and exempts the perpetrators—both interrogators and their bosses—from prosecution for such offenses dating back to November 1997.

15. Toxic Exposure Can Be Transmitted on ‘Second Genetic Code’

Research suggests that, contrary to previous belief, our behavior and our environmental conditions may program sections of our children’s DNA. New evidence about how genes interact with the environment suggests that many industrial chemicals may be more ominously dangerous than previously thought.

16. No Hard Evidence Connecting Bin Laden to 9-11

Osama bin Laden’s supposed role in the events of Sept. 11, 2001, is not even mentioned on the FBI’s “Ten Most Wanted” poster. Why? Because the FBI evidently likes to operate on facts.

17. Drinking Water Contaminated

Despite the federal government’s avowed commitment “to restore and maintain the chemical, physical and biological integrity of the nation’s waters,” corporations, municipalities and the U.S. military pollute our waters—often with little or no accountability.

18. Mexico’s Stolen Election

Overwhelming evidence reveals massive fraud in the 2006 Mexican presidential election between “president-elect” Felipe Calderón of the conservative PAN party and Andrés Manuel López Obrador of the more liberal PRD.

19. People’s Movement Challenges Neoliberal Agenda

There is a successful and growing resistance among Latin American and African leaders to the current “one-size-fits-all” U.S. trade policy model.

20. Terror Act Against Animal Activists

The term “terrorism” has been dangerously expanded to include acts that interfere with, or promote interference in, the operations of animal enterprises.

21. U.S. Seeks WTO Immunity for Illegal Farm Payments

On July 24, 2006, after nearly five years of global trade negotiations, talks at the meetings of the World Trade Organization collapsed. In a last-minute proposal, one not included on the original agenda, the United States suddenly insisted that all trade agreements include a special clause called a “Peace Clause” that would make its use of illegal farm subsidies immune from prosecution by the countries affected.

22. North Invades Mexico

The number of North Americans living in Mexico has soared from 200,000 to 1 million (one-quarter of all U.S. expatriates) in the past decade. With more than 70 million American baby boomers expected to retire in the next two decades, experts predict “a tidal wave” of migration to warmer—and cheaper—climates.

23. Sen. Feinstein’s Conflict of Interest in Iraq

Dianne Feinstein—the ninth wealthiest member of congress—has been beset by monumental ethical conflicts of interest. As a member of the Military Construction Appropriations subcommittee (MILCON) from 2001 to the end of 2005, Sen. Feinstein voted for appropriations worth billions of dollars to her husband’s firms.

Source: “Senator Warbucks” by Peter Byrne. North Bay Bohemian, Jan. 24, 2007.

24. Media Misquotes Threat from Iran’s President

Across the world, a media story has spread that Iran’s president Ahmadinejad has threatened to destroy Israel, by saying that, “Israel must be wiped off the map.” Contrary to general belief, this statement was actually a misinterpretation.

25. Who Will Profit from Native Energy?

The Department of the Interior estimates that Indian lands hold undiscovered reserves of almost 54 billion tons of coal, 38 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, and 5.4 billion barrels of oil. Tribal lands also contain enormous amounts of alternative energy.


Profile: Loudon Wainwright III in Petaluma

0

music & nightlife |

Everyman With A Guitar: Loudon Wainwright III in search of universal truths

By Bruce Robinson

Forty years into his career/lifestyle as an itinerant troubadour, Loudon Wainwright III is enjoying another up-tick in his public profile, courtesy of his work on the soundtrack for director Judd Apatow’s summer comedy, Knocked Up. Songs from the film also form the basis of Wainwright’s latest recording, Strange Weirdos, which has been praised as some of the songwriter’s best work in years.

But the job didn’t arrive just out of the blue. “Judd is a guy I’d worked with before as an actor,” Wainwright recounts by phone from the East coast. “I was in a television show he had a couple of years ago called Undeclared.” That short-lived Fox sitcom casting grew out of Apatow’s long-standing appreciation for Wainwright’s music, and a more recent concert date gave the director some ideas for his newest project.

“He heard a couple of the songs, ‘Grey in L.A.’ and ‘Passion Play,’ which he felt fit into the theme of his movie,” says Wainwright, “and so he said, ‘Why don’t you do the whole enchilada?'” Loudon quickly recruited songwriter and producer Joe Henry as his collaborator for the project, and went to work.

Extracted from the film and presented on their own merits, the songs fit comfortably into the well-established Wainwright mold, a singular distillation of wry humor and brutally honest self-examination that is almost always offered from a first-person perspective.

“Well, I’m always thinking of me,” he admits with a nervous chuckle. “But you see, what happens to me is not unusual to what happens to you and to other people. So I can write about me, but it applies to every man and/or woman. There’s nothing unusual about my life; it’s been a rather mundane existence. But like everybody’s life, there’s a lot of big important things that’ve happened in it and I write about it, and I think people recognize and identify with the songs because that stuff’s happened to them, too.”

In addition to providing the soundtrack, Wainwright also makes a brief acting appearance in Knocked Up, just as he did in Apatow’s previous picture, The 40-Year-Old Virgin. “I thought I wanted to be an actor,” he shrugs, “and occasionally I am.”

So is that Loudon Wainwright we see entertaining onstage just another role he plays? “It’s what I do,” he says matter-of-factly. “It’s a show I give and have been giving since 1968, so that’s almost 40 years. It’s evolved and changed from what it was, as I have. I’m not quite the same person I was when I started in 1968.

“But, uh . . . yes. The answer is yes.”

Loudon Wainwright III appears at the Mystic Theater on Saturday, Sept. 8, at 8pm. 23 Petaluma Blvd. N., Petaluma. $22; 18 and over. 707.765.2121




FIND A MUSIC REVIEW

Taste of Marin

0

What was the most delicious part of Taste of Marin, the posh fundraiser held Aug. 26 at the historic St. Vincent’s School for Boys in San Rafael?Perhaps it was the truly worthy cause: raising money to support the Marin Agricultural Land Trust, Marin Farmers Markets and Marin Organic in their quest to protect the area’s agricultural heritage along with the farmers and ranchers who keep it all going. No surprise, the $150-a-ticket evening was sold-out.It might have been the deluxe reception, held in the front courtyard and brimming with savory hors d’oeuvres, wines and displays of Marin’s best local edibles, hosted by the very talent who grew the ingredients and the chefs who prepared them.

What was the most delicious part of Taste of Marin, the posh fundraiser held Aug. 26 at the historic St. Vincent’s School for Boys in San Rafael?Perhaps it was the truly worthy cause: raising money to support the Marin Agricultural Land Trust, Marin Farmers Markets and Marin Organic in their quest to protect the area’s agricultural heritage along with the farmers and ranchers who keep it all going. No surprise, the $150-a-ticket evening was sold-out.It might have been the deluxe reception, held in the front courtyard and brimming with savory hors d’oeuvres, wines and displays of Marin’s best local edibles, hosted by the very talent who grew the ingredients and the chefs who prepared them.

Such delicacies! We nibbled on roasted plantains stuffed with vegetables under a mantle of melting cheese from Sol Food in San Rafael, and sweet rabbit sausage from Devil’s Gulch Ranch. We slurped tiny shot glasses of oyster-jalapeño ceviche from Drake’s Bay Oyster Farm (divine with a sip of Champagne from Pt. Reyes Vineyards), and ravaged entire legs of goat, lamb and pork from Marin Sun Farms, plucking meat from the bone with our fingers. I’d never before had “wild food paté,” but here it was, crafted by Commonweal Gardens in Bolinas, and like a dense chutney of curly doc seed, nettle leaf, milk thistle seed, sunflower seed and plum slathered on an crisp apple slice.

Certainly it was the sit-down dinner, a new addition to the nine-year-old event. Under a nearly full harvest moon, we sat down to plates laden with Anna’s Daughters Bakery rye bread slathered with Straus Family Creamery butter, and cups of Marin Roots Farm tomato and McEvoy Ranch fennel velouté soup bobbing with homemade olive croutons and Fresh Run Farm basil.

For the next several hours, we feasted on eight more high-pedigree courses including a ravishing local wild king salmon with Little Organic Farm purple potatoes and Star Route Farms purslane in a green goddess dressing of Cow Track Ranch garlic and chives, followed by a salad of roasted Fresh Run Farm chioggia beets, Marin Roots Farm golden beets, Andante Dairy Acapella goat cheese and Cowgirl Creamery Mt. Tam cheese atop Star Route Farms mixed greens drizzled in Marshall’s Farm honey and McEvoy Ranch olive oil.

But absolutely, the tastiest part of the evening was the sales pitch my table received for membership in the nonprofit activity. As dinner began, a very attractive volunteer for one of the organizations seated herself at our table, and, sipping beer, extolled the virtues of her group with great encouragement for us to join. After a bit more beer, her extolment flipped to the virtues of the men such membership attracted—loudly pointing out, in fact, a nearby guest who’d joined, well, her at this same party last year (up against a wall of this very school, it turned out, and with nary a sign-up sheet in hand). More beer, and our passionate hostess was bidding on a raffle prize for a private tour of Mt. Tam’s back roads, described as being led by “stalwart young rangers” of the Marin Fire department (“Orgy!” she shrieked).

By the time I left, our saucy salesperson had one new male enrollee whispering in her ear, another tugging her arm for a whirl on the dance floor, and another at our table yelping “Me next!” Sold!

For more info, contact Marin Agricultural Land Trust (www.malt.org), Marin Farmers Markets (www.marinfarmersmarket.org) and Marin Organic (www.marinorganic.org)



SEARCH AVAILABLE RESERVATIONS & BOOK A TABLE

View All


Quick dining snapshots by Bohemian staffers.


Winery news and reviews.


Food-related comings and goings, openings and closings, and other essays for those who love the kitchen and what it produces.


Recipes for food that you can actually make.

Green Zone: Eco-News for Sonoma, Marin and Napa

September 5-11, 2007

you tried it lately?

If electric vehicles are not the “green” solution, if even good gas mileage is still bad gas mileage, then what is the best way to get around? Who are the real transportation eco-warriors? This line of questioning led me to the city bus system.

In 14 years of living in Sonoma County, the only bus I have ever ridden is the San Francisco Airporter. For the last six years, I’ve driven by the bus stop that’s a short half-mile walk from my house, and never once have I stood beside the rickety post that sits, desolate on Highway 116, surrounded by weeds. How hard can it be?

My new goal: to ride the bus to the Santa Rosa Transit Mall from Sebastopol, preferably starting from that lonely bus stop that is walking distance from my house, and then ride it back again. Bus schedules are available at the local library, so that’s where I get mine. I also call the transit line, where a city employee cheerfully helps me find my way from point A to point B. Unfortunately, that little bus stop, the one that I imagine myself standing next to as I wait patiently, stoically even, under the blazing sun for my bus to appear, only goes to Rohnert Park. If I want to get to Santa Rosa, I have to somehow travel the five miles into Sebastopol and catch my ride there. No big deal; I have a car. If I didn’t, well, the transit system would have already let me down.

I park my car a couple of blocks from the Sebastopol Post Office, jog down to the bus stop and sit down to wait. A nice-looking young man waits next to me. After a few minutes of silence, he asks me if he can smoke. I say, “Sure, but can I ask you a couple of questions?” and we go from there. A 19-year-old West County native, Matthew Thomas, has been utilizing the public bus system for the last four years. In Matthew’s opinion, the system has been going seriously downhill. This used to be the easiest way to get around, he tells me, but now, with the consistent schedule changes, unpredictable arrival times and route cutbacks, riding the bus is no longer an easy solution. “Oh,” Matthew adds with a touch of cynicism, “and they’re always late.”

Our bus is, indeed, 10 minutes late, but once it arrives, proves to be quite serviceable. With an 18-passenger capacity, the bus is a little less than half full. I take a seat in the back and am soon lulled to sleep as we bounce and speed down the highway, making it to the transit mall in just under 15 minutes.

By the time I disembark, I’m feeling pleased. Refreshed by my catnap, I’m now sure that riding the bus isn’t so bad, as long as I don’t need to depend on it specifically. For instance, if I had no car and a bad limp, I would have a hell of a time getting to Santa Rosa every day for work. But considering my privileged position, I can afford to be flexible. Then I look at the posted schedules and realize that the next bus heading for Sebastopol doesn’t leave for three hours and that it will be a 40-minute trip back. Apparently, bus travel on a Saturday was not the spiffiest idea.

In order to spare myself the tedium, I call some friends and arrange for them to pick me up in their family postal truck/RV that they run on biodiesel. (The transit mall, by the way, is notably free of fumes despite the buses pulling in and out. This is no doubt due to the fact that all of the buses run on natural gas, as opposed to the stinking, black fume-spewing diesel buses of my childhood.)

The postal truck eventually arrives. I board and we roar back to Sebastopol with both side doors open, the highway spinning below our feet. Just shy of town, we stop at the Chevron station on Highway 12 that recently began selling biodiesel. We’re not the only ones filling up, and with over 2,000 gallons of biodiesel per month being sold from this particular station, it’s heartening to witness firsthand the community interest in alternative fuels. Biodiesel may have its drawbacks, but it is grown and processed in the U.S. and reduces carbon emissions by a reported 48 percent. At $3.79 a gallon, compared to $3.09 for a gallon of diesel, I guess one could say that it had better.

So, I need a car to catch the bus, and I need a diesel to buy biodiesel, and I need a certain level of generosity and willingness to sacrifice convenience to do either. But think about it: if every single adult in the North Bay made a personal commitment to ride the bus just once a week, that could make a huge difference. In fact, the counties would probably have to add a bunch of new lines just to accommodate us all, which would make life easier for real bus riders, like Matthew. Besides, it’s relaxing to ride the bus. You don’t have to worry, road rage falls away and as long as the buses are clean, the lull of community travel can truly surround one in a soothing, low-emissions bubble of serenity.

Find out more about your local transit system by visiting wwwsctransit.com

707.576.7433

www.marintransit.org

415.256.8832

www.nctpa.net

707.259.8631


Letters to the Editor

August 22-September 4, 2007

What’s Right, What’s Easy?

In response to Peter Byrne’s column, “Muggles, Arise!” (Aug. 15), I hasten to remind Mr. Byrne that one shouldn’t judge a book by how it’s covered in the media. From the start, Harry Potter has been mischaracterized by corporate interests as a kids’ book about sorcery. No doubt this mischaracterization is due to the subversive philosophy that Rowling subtly delivers to her readers. Rowling has said that, to her, the moral significance of the tales is “the choice between what is right and what is easy,” explaining that “tyranny [is] started by people being apathetic and taking the easy route and suddenly finding themselves in deep trouble.”

Pity poor Harry Potter. He knows that Voldemort is back, but is ridiculed by the press and government. Most of his school is turned against him because they only know what the media and their leaders promote. The book raises an interesting question: What would you do if your government were infiltrated by enemies of freedom and liberty? In Harry’s case, he organizes a forbidden group to resist the evil. Far from being just a dumb kids’ book, Harry Potter is likely to be the one cultural event of the century that the world will share globally. Its popularity and the message of choosing to do what is right, no matter how harsh the personal consequences, makes it the possibly the most subversive and influential book since the Bible. God knows that the messages in that book, like “The truth will set you free” and “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you,” are not views that our current leaders promote.

John Rose, Santa Rosa

Wizards, Unite!

Silly Peter Byrne! To say that we’re all Muggles and the elite are the wizards is simplistic and just plain wrong. Those of us who engage in radical creativity as activist writers, songsters, punk rockers, dancers, poets and green architects; who create alternative media, are playwrights, graffiti artists, conscious rappers, cop watchers, open mic’ers, “burners” and bioneers are all wizards, for we deal in the magic of imagination to create social change.

It’s those who have never questioned reality, who sit like lumps in front of TVs and are obedient consumers, who are Muggles. Behind the wheels of every SUV sits a Muggle.

J. K. Rowling is stirring up the powerful latent magic of creative transformation within us, for we truly are in an epic struggle. The Dark Side certainly has its wizards, who, through cunning and deceit, have attained positions of great power. We can and must outwit them! Why, the Republicans are now running R. G. Voldemort for president.

Forest Staggs, Petaluma

Peter spends each of the precious 800 words allotted him this week rebutting these two letters. See “The Byrne Report,” p9.

Not one or t’other

Did I miss something (Letters, Aug. 22)? Does there have to be a choice between “Ask Sydney” and Rob Brezsny? Sydney is solid and answers a few questions in a refreshingly earthy manner. Rob is a poet and guides us with rich analogy and humor and addresses the 12 astrological paths. The work is different! Rob was my lure to the Bohemian. Don’t lose me.

Andee Kobus-Sheard , Santa Rosa

If we are foolish enough to misprint or forget to print Rob Brezsny’s Free Will Astrology, we are immediately punished by having to read his horoscope to legions over the phone. There is no way that we would take the misguided step of offing our favorite Marin-based astrologer; this ain’t no “either or.” Sydney wanted to leave. We miss her too, but that’s the last word.

Dept. of forehead-slapping

In the magnificent round-up otherwise known as Fall Arts Listings (“Fall into Arts,” Aug. 22), we made two remarkable errors—remarkable, that is, for their sheer stupidity.

We have received many, many, many notices that Napa’s River Festival (formerly set for Sept. 2) has been cancelled this year, yet we doggedly printed notice of it. Our failure in regards to Face to Face’s Art for Life annual auction was more internally egregious. We had the listing, wrong dates; we had the listing, wrong price; we had an image to support the listing, Chaka Khan went there instead. And lo, when we went to print, no listing at all! Please mark Sept. 6&–8 on the calendar for this 20th anniversary fundraiser featuring 20 new artists. Still at Santa Rosa’s Friedman Center, the auction proper is slated for Saturday, Sept. 8; tickets are $75. For details, go to www.f2f.org.

The Ed.

embarrassed, contrite and strangely hungry for canapes


Harvard racism test

0

08.29.07

People don’t know themselves,” says Brian Nosek, “as well as it feels like we know ourselves.”

Speaking from the psychology department at the University of Virginia, Nosek should know. He’s developed an online test that’s caused people around the world to shake their fists, bang the keyboard and shudder in resentment when presented with results that go against the very core of their values. Nosek’s research never comes right out and asks, although there’s nonetheless an underlying question at play.

What if, deep down, we are all racist?

Enter Project Implicit, designers of the online Implicit Association Test (IAT), hosted at Harvard University, which aims to dig beneath the surface of the mind by measuring automatic responses to images quickly flashed on the screen. Designed by Anthony Greenwald, a psychology professor at the University of Washington, the IAT was co-developed with Nosek, a co-principal investigator of Project Implicit.

Harvard’s website contains 14 different IATs for biases regarding weight, age, sexuality and disability, but by far, the race test is the most popular—and provocative. At the start of the IAT, test takers answer questions about their feelings toward white and black people, along with some general inquiries to the person’s character—how impulsive they may see themselves, how they feel about human equality. After a basic warm-up sorting faces and words, the real task begins—sorting white and black faces into groups of “good” and “bad” along with words like “nasty,” “glorious,” “hurt,” “love,” “failure” and “happy.”

Taking the test can be extremely maddening. At times, it forces the testee to lump black faces with words like “evil” and “horrible,” destroying the honed alignment of what hopefully are our basic humanitarian values. But what we think may be a difficult association to make turns out to be easier than we realize; the Project Implicit website keeps a tally of split-second time results, and most respondents react quicker while sorting black faces with “awful” and “agony” than with “pleasure” and “laughter.”

In other words, everyone is racist. Right?

Not at all, says Nosek. “Racism is explicit,” he says. “Racism is me saying, ‘I don’t like this group because I think they’re rotten and ugly and smelly.’ That’s not what the IAT measures; it’s not telling us what the truth is in someone’s mind.”

What it does measure is mental association and “automatic preference,” the term used in test results (i.e., “You have a moderate automatic preference for European Americans over African Americans”). No one likes this terminology very much, but Nosek is clear about the subconscious definition of “automatic preference” as used in the test, citing his own testing experience as an example.

“I hold the idea of treating everyone as individuals and not by the color of their skin,” he says, “and nonetheless, it’s easier for me to group ‘black’ with ‘bad’ and ‘white’ with ‘good’ than the other way around. That suggests something very surprising and humbling to me; one is that I don’t have complete control over my mind. There’s stuff in my mind that exists there without my permission, without necessarily my desiring it and without my necessarily being able to control it.

“And so what that introduces,” he continues, “is that I may be behaving in ways that are inconsistent with my values without even really recognizing it. That is something that we don’t like to think about as humans. We want to think we’re in control of our minds and our behavior.”

In other words, the test results really aren’t as personal as we may think. While our conscious mind processes the relationships among stimuli it receives and scrutinizes their worth, our implicit mind—the side the IAT aims to probe—merely records its environment, making the test more of a barometer of the world around us than of our true makeup.

Still, many people feel that they’re accused of racism when their test result denotes a moderate automatic preference for white people over black people or vice versa, and almost all of them have theories about the IAT’s flaws.

“My biggest problem,” writes one online user, “is that the real response they’re measuring is how quickly they can get me to associate positive terms with my right hand and negative terms with my left, then how well I cope when they mix things up. I see very little here to persuade me that they’ve accurately measured what they claim to have measured.”

Nosek himself thought of this after he first took the IAT, and after investigation determined that the switch-up only provides for a 3 percent effect on test performance. “It feels like it must be the whole explanation when we do it,” he says, “but it actually has a very small impact, and we’ve added some procedural modifications to reduce that impact even further.”

Nosek himself welcomes debate on the IAT (it gets “everyday people to think like scientists,” he says), but more important, he says, is the communication and self-awareness the test can inspire. Whatever one may think of the IAT test, it nonetheless serves as a catalyst for us to face our own biases.

“There’s a lot of interesting social issues that we want to wrestle with as a society and also individually,” Nosek says. “This test can be a vehicle for promoting that discussion, and I don’t think conversations like that are ever harmful.”

The question remains: are we all racist?

The Project Implicit tests can be found online at https://implicit.harvard.edu.implicit.


The Byrne Report

September 5-11, 2007Despite—or perhaps because of—the fact that nationalist Iraqi militias have largely defeated the American invasion of their country, ordinary Americans who have silently opposed the war remain quiet. With the exception of a few groups, notably Code Pink, the peace movement has been missing in action for four years. And that is one reason why Bush can...

Stage review: ‘The Clean House’ at Cinnabar

the arts | stage | Photograph by Jeff Thomas Couch...

Project Censored

Photograph by Edward Troxell ...

Profile: Loudon Wainwright III in Petaluma

music & nightlife | Everyman With A Guitar: Loudon...

Green Zone: Eco-News for Sonoma, Marin and Napa

September 5-11, 2007you tried it lately?If electric vehicles are not the "green" solution, if even good gas mileage is still bad gas mileage, then what is the best way to get around? Who are the real transportation eco-warriors? This line of questioning led me to the city bus system. In 14 years of living in Sonoma County, the...

Letters to the Editor

August 22-September 4, 2007What's Right, What's Easy?In response to Peter Byrne's column, "Muggles, Arise!" (Aug. 15), I hasten to remind Mr. Byrne that one shouldn't judge a book by how it's covered in the media. From the start, Harry Potter has been mischaracterized by corporate interests as a kids' book about sorcery. No doubt this mischaracterization is due to...

Harvard racism test

08.29.07People don't know themselves," says Brian Nosek, "as well as it feels like we know ourselves." Speaking from the psychology department at the University of Virginia, Nosek should know. He's developed an online test that's caused people around the world to shake their fists, bang the keyboard and shudder in resentment when presented with results that go against the...
11,084FansLike
4,606FollowersFollow
6,928FollowersFollow