Nouveau Quiche

Reclaiming meat-and-egg pie

I like quiche, I don’t care what they say—and what was it they said about quiche?

Much has changed since a snarky scribe wrote the bestselling Real Men Don’t Eat Quiche: A Guidebook to All That Is Truly Masculine in 1982. The dish became collateral damage against a backdrop of changing gender roles, the questioning of men’s privilege in the workplace and a political swing to the right after a disoriented American public elected a strongman-type television personality who promised to bring back the nation’s past glories. I know, it seems like a long time ago. But how’s the quiche doing today?

“I don’t think the millennials know about that,” the Girl & the Fig founder Sondra Bernstein says of the authenticity-driven male embargo. “We sell a ton of quiche—I don’t think it’s a gender thing anymore.” As of December, the restaurant had sold an estimated 8,000 slices of their light and fluffy quiche in 2017.

These days, few people who have heard of the don’t-eat edict can identify its origin as the title of a satirical book that was, like much satire, mistaken for an instruction manual. Indeed, author Bruce Feirstein anticipated the objection that few men would refuse a helping of “cheese-and-egg pie,” without the Gallic taint (quiche, née küche, actually comes from German cuisine, a sidekick to bratwurst and beer).

It sure was lost in translation for French-born Alain Pisan. “I remember when my wife first told me about this expression,” the chef recalls, “it made me laugh at the silliness of it. Fortunately, we haven’t seen many men rebelling against quiche for the past two decades.” Quiche made from a family recipe was a popular item at Chloe’s French Café, the Santa Rosa eatery that Pisan cofounded and closed due to the 2017 fires. “Its popularity continues with our catering operation,” he says.

Cheese educator Lynne Devereux reminds me that quiche got a bad rap during a reputedly health-conscious decade, when many women traded the quiche and salad brunch for, well, salad.

“It’s part of that fat phobia that reigned in the ’80s,” says Devereux. “It’s glistening on the top because all the oils of the cheese have come to the top and made it all shiny. There’s fat in the crust—there’s fat in the filling! So it kind of became one of those ‘bad’ foods.”

That’s all good for Jean-Charles Boisset, a red-blooded captain of industry. “I think quiche can be a textural, sensual, seductive experience,” Boisset days. “And I love the word ‘quiche,'” Boisset enthuses. “Your lips move forward—you could even kiss the wall, or your plate. I used to kiss my plate.”

OK—I should have said “red-sock-wearing,” and clarified we’re talking about the wine industry here. But Boisset, who is perhaps California’s best-known Frenchman, knows of what he speaks, having fond memories of quiche and other season-to-table foods made by his mother and grandmother in Vougeot, Burgundy.

Boisset recommends pairing quiche with a rich Chardonnay or Pinot Noir made with Gruyère or Emmental, then finished with French Comté cheese aged 18 months. “You do that, and you’re gonna have an orgasmic experience,” Boisset says.


Winter Mushroom Crust Quiche

I merged two recipes to make this one, mixing it up with local ingredients. I’m thinking that, because it’s still winter, a savory quiche which was a favorite on my family’s table years ago fits the seasonal bill: it’s made with a crust of mushrooms rather than pastry.

This quiche doesn’t need meat to feel hearty, but I’ll add more mushrooms to the filling, and some kale that’s happily overwintering in my garden for a healthy dose of greens—and on a hunch that kale will add less water than chard or spinach when it cooks.

The main hitch in sourcing local cheese is that there’s no Emmental-equivalent made here—local creameries with Swiss-Italian heritage, like Valley Ford, make an Italian mountain-style cheese, while Bernstein uses Joe Matos St. George.

The mushroom crust lends the dish to easy gluten-free conversion. I made serviceable breadcrumbs by drying a gluten-free burger bun in the oven, then spinning it in the food processor. One great feature of quiche is that you can wing it a bit and turn out a perfectly edible pie. But I did not go so far as to imagine a vegan version. I mean, quelle horreur!


8 ounces cremini mushrooms

1/2 c. bread crumbs

2 tbsp. ground flaxseed

5 tbsp. butter or olive oil

8 ounces Bellwether Farms sheep milk ricotta (or substitute plain sheep milk yogurt)

1 c. shredded cheese: Point Reyes Toma, Valley Ford Estero Gold (substitute Beaufort, Emmental, Gruyère)

3 medium-large eggs

2 shallots, diced

1 c. chopped lacinato “dinosaur” kale

4 ounces oyster or other farmers market mushroom

1/2 tsp. horseradish

1/2 tsp. thyme leaves


Mince mushrooms. Sauté in 3 tablespoons of butter or oil about 5 minutes. Mix with bread crumbs and flaxseed, and press mixture into a greased nine-inch pie pan. This is the hard part. You’ll question the exercise: how can something so poorly executed and futile be effeminate? You’re closer than you think: fill in the gaps, stick with it, or use more mushrooms and crumbs in the recipe to ensure the pan’s covered.

For the filling, beat eggs, mix with ricotta or yogurt and herbs. Add a few ounces half-and-half if the mixture doesn’t seem pourable. In skillet, sauté shallots and sliced specialty mushrooms with remaining butter or oil. Then either layer with kale on the crust and pour mixture over, or fold veggies into the mixture, then pour.

Bake 30-45 minutes at 375 degrees should do it. Stick a fork in it, man!

Previous articleRoad Ration
Next articleOn the Hunt